by Gianfranco Conti, PhD. Co-author of 'The Language Teacher toolkit', 'Breaking the sound barrier: teaching learners how to listen', 'Memory: what every teacher should know' and of the 'Sentence Builders' book series. Winner of the 2015 TES best resource contributor award, founder and CEO of www.language-gym.com, co-founder of www.sentencebuilders.com and creator of the E.P.I. approach.
Nine activities. One goal: making sentence production faster, more accurate and more automatic.
One of the greatest challenges in language teaching is bridging the gap between knowing vocabulary and grammar and being able to retrieve and deploy that knowledge accurately, fluently and under time pressure. A student may recognise every word in a sentence, understand the grammar rule governing its construction and even translate it correctly when given enough time. Yet ask that same student to produce the sentence spontaneously, and the whole process often grinds to a halt.
Why? The main reason is that knowing the components of a language is not the same as being able to assemble them efficiently in real time.
This is precisely the challenge that The Language Gym’s Sentence Trainer was designed to address by implementing process-based instruction: rather than treating sentence production as a single, indivisible skill, the Sentence Trainer offers nine activities targeting different aspects of the processing involved in retrieving, assembling, monitoring and producing sentences.
1. Why sentence-level practice matters
In instructed second language acquisition, a fundamental distinction is made between declarative knowledge (what learners know about the language) and procedural knowledge (what learners can actually do with it). In other words, a learner might know that a French reflexive verb requires a reflexive pronoun, but still struggle to produce Je me lève à sept heures quickly and accurately.
Producing even a relatively simple sentence requires the coordination of several processes:
Retrieving the relevant vocabulary and multiword chunks.
Selecting appropriate grammatical structures.
Assembling words into a meaningful, well-formed sentence.
Accessing accurate orthographic or phonological representations.
Monitoring the output for errors.
Doing all of the above within the constraints of working memory.
When these processes are insufficiently practised, sentence production becomes slow, effortful and error-prone.
The pedagogical answer is not simply to explain the grammar again. It is to provide structured opportunities to practise the processes that make accurate language production possible.
2. Nine activities, nine opportunities to strengthen sentence processing
The Sentence Trainer currently features nine activities, each providing a different form of sentence-level practice.
Sentence Puzzle invites learners to reconstruct sentences from their constituent elements. Its potential value lies in directing attention towards word order, grammatical relationships and the organisation of meaningful chunks. Rather than recalling isolated vocabulary, learners must consider how words fit together to produce a coherent utterance.
This can support the development of sentence assembly skills, particularly when learners subsequently practise producing the same structures without prompts.
Trapdoor — Repeated processing with variation
Trapdoor provides a framework for repeated encounters with sentence patterns while introducing variation. This combination is pedagogically valuable because repetition supports consolidation, while variation can encourage learners to attend to the elements that change and those that remain constant. The aim is not simply to memorise one sentence, but to become increasingly familiar with a family of related constructions.
Gapped Sentences — Production under constraints
Gapped Sentences requires learners to complete sentences by supplying missing words or chunks. Unlike activities where all the linguistic elements are provided, gapped sentences introduce a retrieval demand: learners must identify what is missing and recover the appropriate language from memory. The surrounding sentence provides contextual and grammatical cues, making the task less demanding than producing an entire sentence independently.
This makes Gapped Sentences particularly useful for strengthening:
Lexical retrieval: recovering words and chunks from memory.
Grammatical selection: choosing forms appropriate to the sentence context.
Collocational knowledge: recognising which words naturally occur together.
Form–meaning connections: retrieving language that fits both the intended meaning and the grammatical structure.
Accuracy monitoring: checking that the completed sentence is well formed.
The pedagogical value lies in the balance between support and retrieval demand.
A well-designed gap directs learners’ attention towards a particular linguistic feature while preserving enough context to make successful retrieval possible. As learners become more proficient, support can be gradually reduced and the retrieval demands increased.
Gapped sentences are therefore a useful bridge between recognition and independent sentence production.
Anagrams — Orthographic retrieval and reconstruction
Anagrams targets the ability to reconstruct written language from disordered elements. Such practice can strengthen attention to letter sequences and orthographic accuracy. This is particularly relevant in languages where spelling presents significant challenges, including French.
However, orthographic reconstruction should complement, rather than replace, meaningful sentence production.
Beat the Robot — Retrieval under time pressure
Beat the Robot introduces a competitive, time-sensitive dimension to practice. Time pressure can encourage learners to retrieve familiar language more rapidly, reducing their reliance on slow, deliberate reconstruction. The important qualification is that speed should be introduced after sufficient modelling and accuracy-focused practice.
Premature speed can reinforce errors; appropriately timed speed can help consolidate accurate retrieval.
Dictation — From sound to written language
Dictation is far more than a spelling exercise. To transcribe a spoken sentence, learners must identify the speech stream, segment it into words, recognise familiar sequences, retrieve orthographic representations and monitor what they have written. It therefore brings together listening, phonological processing, lexical recognition and written accuracy. This makes it especially valuable in languages where sound–spelling correspondences are challenging.
Delayed Dictation — Holding and reconstructing language
Delayed Dictation introduces a memory demand by separating exposure to the spoken input from its written reproduction. This encourages learners to maintain and reconstruct linguistic information rather than simply transcribe it immediately. The activity can therefore place demands on verbal working memory, lexical retention and sentence reconstruction.
The delay must, however, be calibrated carefully. Excessive memory load can overwhelm learners before they have had the opportunity to process the language successfully.
Delayed Copying requires learners to retain written language briefly before reproducing it. Unlike ordinary copying, which can become a largely mechanical exercise, delayed copying creates a retrieval demand. Learners must attend more closely to spelling, word order and the structure of the sentence. With appropriate scaffolding, this can encourage more active processing of written language.
Translation — Retrieving and assembling language from meaning
Translation provides a particularly useful bridge between meaning and form. When learners translate into the target language, they must retrieve vocabulary, select grammatical structures and assemble a sentence that conveys the intended meaning. Unlike recognition tasks, translation can require substantial independent production. It also provides opportunities for diagnostic feedback: errors can reveal difficulties with lexical retrieval, sentence assembly, grammatical selection or orthographic accuracy.
Translation is therefore most useful when it is embedded within a wider progression of modelling, guided practice and increasingly independent language use.
3. Why the combination matters more than any single activity
The strength of the Sentence Trainer is not simply that it offers nine different exercises. It is that these activities can be combined to create a progression from supported processing to increasingly independent production. Some tasks provide substantial linguistic support. Others place greater demands on retrieval, memory, accuracy or speed. This is important because fluent language production does not emerge merely from repeated exposure to vocabulary and grammar rules. Learners need opportunities to retrieve and manipulate familiar language across different conditions.
The sequence should not be rigid. A teacher might begin with sentence reconstruction, move towards retrieval-based production, introduce dictation for sound–spelling consolidation and finish with translation or timed practice.
What matters is that the activities are selected according to the processing demands learners are ready to handle, not simply for variety or entertainment.
4. The connection with cognitive science and second language acquisition
Several research traditions help explain why this kind of practice can be valuable.
Skill Acquisition Theory (DeKeyser, 2007) emphasises the role of practice in developing increasingly efficient performance. Repeated, meaningful opportunities to apply linguistic knowledge can reduce the attentional demands of language production.
Retrieval practice research (Karpicke & Roediger, 2008) demonstrates that retrieving information from memory can strengthen subsequent retention. Activities requiring learners to reconstruct language without constantly referring to a model are therefore potentially more valuable for retention than repeated passive review.
Working memory research (Baddeley, 2000; Cowan, 2001) reminds us that the capacity to hold and manipulate unfamiliar information is limited. This provides a rationale for carefully controlling task complexity, particularly with novice learners.
Transfer-appropriate processing (Morris, Bransford & Franks, 1977) suggests that learning benefits when practice engages processes relevant to subsequent performance. If the goal is accurate sentence production, learners need more than recognition exercises: they need to practise retrieving, assembling and producing sentences.
None of these theories establishes that a particular digital activity automatically produces fluency. The benefits depend on how the activity is designed, sequenced, supported and followed up.
5. Where the Sentence Trainer fits into EPI
Within Extensive Processing Instruction, the Sentence Trainer can be particularly useful during the transition from intensive modelling to increasingly independent production.
After learners have encountered and processed target constructions through listening and reading, the Trainer can provide additional opportunities for consolidation.
Its activities can support several complementary objectives:
Retrieval: encouraging access to language without continuous visual support.
Accuracy: focusing attention on sentence structure, spelling and grammatical choices.
Automaticity: increasing the efficiency of familiar retrieval and assembly processes.
Diagnostic assessment: helping teachers identify which aspects of sentence processing remain insecure.
It can also be used for homework, retrieval starters and additional practice between lessons.
Crucially, the Trainer should not replace communicative language use. Rather, it can help prepare learners for the demands of communication by strengthening some of the component processes on which it depends.
6. An added bonus
The Sentence Trainer recycles every single item in the Rock-Climbing game. Hence, it is great either as a primer, to prepare the students for the Rock-Climbing game or as a consolidator after playing that game.
Conclusions
We would never expect a basketball player to become proficient simply by memorising the rules of basketball nor would we expect them to improve solely by playing full matches without practising shooting, passing, dribbling, movement and decision-making. Language learning is very much the same!
If we want students to produce accurate, fluent sentences, we must give them opportunities to practise the underlying processes: lexical retrieval, sentence assembly, grammatical selection, spelling, monitoring and increasingly rapid access to familiar constructions.
The Sentence Trainer is designed around this principle: help learners become better at the processes that underpin successful language performance.
References
Baddeley, A. (2000). The episodic buffer: A new component of working memory? Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 4(11), 417–423.
Cowan, N. (2001). The magical number 4 in short-term memory: A reconsideration of mental storage capacity. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 24(1), 87–114.
DeKeyser, R. (Ed.). (2007). Practice in a Second Language: Perspectives from Applied Linguistics and Cognitive Psychology. Cambridge University Press.
Karpicke, J. D., & Roediger, H. L. (2008). The critical importance of retrieval for learning. Science, 319, 966–968.
Morris, C. D., Bransford, J. D., & Franks, J. J. (1977). Levels of processing versus transfer appropriate processing. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 16(5), 519–533.
Why getting grammar right does not necessarily mean getting it — and how assessment can genuinely advance acquisition.
Introduction: What are we actually assessing?
Imagine a Year 10 French class completing a sequence on the passé composé and imparfait. After modelling, listening, reading, retrieval and structured output, students average 85% on a grammar quiz. The result is encouraging. But what exactly does that 85% tell us? Can they identify the contrast in speech? Understand how it changes meaning? Retrieve the forms without prompts? Select them while narrating an unfamiliar experience? Still use them three weeks later?
Accuracy is evidence of performance under particular conditions, not a direct measure of acquisition. Ellis (2005, 2009) distinguishes different kinds of grammatical knowledge and the difficulties involved in measuring them. VanPatten (1996, 2004) shows why processing grammatical form in input cannot be taken for granted. Pienemann (1998) proposes developmental constraints on grammatical processing; DeKeyser (1997, 2007) examines how practice can make skills increasingly efficient. Bjork and Bjork (2011) distinguish immediate accessibility from durable learning.
A danger of mini-whiteboards, quizzes and other quick checks is that the easier a response is to collect and count, the easier it becomes to overinterpret it. Thirty correct answers might reflect recognition, a recently rehearsed rule, copied language or independent retrieval. These are not interchangeable. Equally, an incorrect response may reflect a processing bottleneck, unfamiliar vocabulary or task pressure rather than the absence of relevant grammatical knowledge. The question is not simply “Who got it right?” but “What did this task require, what can I legitimately infer, and what should I teach next?”
The three stages of grammatical skill acquisition
Skill Acquisition Theory, drawing on Anderson (1982, 1983) and applied to L2 morphosyntax by DeKeyser (1997, 2007), provides a useful three-stage account of how practice can change grammatical performance. In the declarative stage, learners can consciously recognise or apply rules, often slowly and with support. During proceduralisation, retrieval and application become increasingly accurate and efficient, although still variable and attention-demanding. With automatisation, well-practised procedures can become more fluent, reliable and less demanding, freeing attention for meaning and communication. Whilst the first stage can be attained after a few hours of practice, automatization may require 100s.
Figure 1. A simplified account of grammatical skill development (Anderson, 1982; DeKeyser, 1997, 2007).
These categories must guide our assessment inferences. A multiple-choice item may provide evidence of recognition; a translation without a model may probe independent retrieval; an unrehearsed exchange with an unexpected follow-up can probe flexible use under communicative pressure. None is a pure test of an internal stage, and automaticity cannot be established from one successful response. Nor does Skill Acquisition Theory imply that all implicit L2 knowledge originates in explicit rules. Pienemann’s Processability Theory concerns developmental constraints and should not be conflated with the efficiency changes described by skill theory. A learner may be accurate yet slow, quick yet unreliable, or fluent with one construction but not another.
The fourteen principles at a glance
Principle
Assessment question
Research
1. Alignment
Does the task assess the intended skill?
Biggs, 1996
2. Validity
What conclusion does this performance support?
Messick, 1989; Ellis, 2005
3. Diagnosticity
Where does difficulty arise?
Ellis, 2005; DeKeyser, 2007
4. Triangulation
Does performance hold across task types?
Bachman & Palmer, 1996; Ellis, 2009
5. Developmental appropriateness
What can learners do without support?
Pienemann, 1998
6. Cognitive load
How does complexity change performance?
Sweller, 1988; DeKeyser, 2007
7. Form–meaning processing
Are grammatical cues used to understand?
VanPatten, 1996, 2004
8. Actionable feedback
Does correction transfer?
Lyster & Saito, 2010
9. Responsiveness
What instructional response fits the evidence?
Black & Wiliam, 2009
10. Retrieval and spacing
Can forms be retrieved after intervals?
Roediger & Karpicke, 2006
11. Durable learning
Does performance survive delay and novelty?
Bjork & Bjork, 2011
12. Learner agency
Can students monitor their own output?
Sadler, 1989; Nicol & Macfarlane-Dick, 2006
13. Reassessment
Did the response make a difference?
Black & Wiliam, 2009
14. Equity and inclusion
Are irrelevant barriers distorting evidence?
Messick, 1989; CAST, 2018
1. Alignment: assess the skill, not merely the topic
Biggs (1996)
We sometimes say that students have ‘done the past tense’, as though a grammatical topic were a single skill that could just be ticked off. Yet recognising a past form in speech, understanding the time relationship it expresses, selecting an auxiliary and narrating an event are quite different achievements!
Biggs’ (1996) principle of constructive alignment gives us a useful starting point: before assessing anything, specify what learners should actually be able to do. If our goal is comprehension, a conjugation table is not a substitute for evidence of comprehension.
Suppose the target is interpreting time reference in spoken French. Read aloud Je fais du sport, J’ai fait du sport and Je vais faire du sport, without displaying the sentences or supplying time adverbs. Students show PRESENT, PAST or FUTURE on their mini-whiteboards. Repeat with different familiar verbs and, once the contrast is secure, longer utterances. If the objective instead concerns German weil-clauses, students might listen to a justification and identify the reason expressed; if the goal is production, they must construct a justification themselves.
Correct responses in the French task suggest that students can discriminate and interpret those spoken constructions; they do not tell us whether they could produce them. Where answers are weak, I would first establish whether students heard the relevant forms accurately before reteaching their meaning. The quality of the assessment depends on the match between the intended skill and the processing the task actually requires.
2. Validity: correct does not necessarily mean acquired
Messick (1989); Ellis (2005)
A high score is seductive but it is also remarkably easy to overinterpret. Validity, in Messick’s (1989) sense, concerns whether the interpretation we attach to a result is truly warranted. A learner who select voyagerais rather than voyagerai may be recognising a familiar pattern or consciously applying a rule. Neither response tells us, on its own, how that learner would manage an unexpected question in conversation. Ellis (2005) is particularly relevant here: different tasks place different demands on grammatical knowledge. The question is not simply whether the answer is correct, but what that correctness allows us to infer.
Display Si j’avais plus de temps, je… and ask the students to choose between voyagerai and voyagerais. Then remove the model and ask for a translation of ‘If I had more money, I would travel more.’ A further check might ask them to respond, without preparation, to Que ferais-tu pour améliorer ton école ? These tasks progressively reduce the cues available and increases the need to select language independently.
If students succeed on the choice but struggle to construct the sentence, that is useful information about the gap between recognition and retrieval. If they produce a correct translation but hesitate in conversation, we should not automatically infer that the grammar is absent: speaking imposes additional demands. Validity resides in the claims we make from the evidence, not in the apparent neatness of the score.
3. Diagnosticity: the same error can conceal different problems
Ellis (2005); DeKeyser (2007)
Two learners may make exactly the same error for entirely different reasons ! One has not noticed the ending; another recognises it but attaches the wrong meaning to it; a third knows the distinction yet cannot retrieve the appropriate form quickly enough while speaking. A mark scheme records the error but diagnostic assessment asks what might have produced it. This matters because the remedy should depend on the difficulty, not merely on the visible mistake (Ellis, 2005; DeKeyser, 2007).
Consider the French contrast Je jouais au football / J’ai joué au football. Without obvious time adverbs, ask students how the two forms present the past event: the imperfective view from within the situation, as opposed to a bounded event. Then supply short contexts in which one interpretation is appropriate, before asking students to produce a fresh sentence about what they were doing when something happened. In a separate listening check, compare je fais and j’ai fait: first establish whether students can hear the contrast, then whether they can interpret it, and finally whether they can retrieve it.
The pattern of responses is more informative than any single answer. A learner who hears the forms but misinterprets them needs a different response from one who understands the contrast but cannot construct it. Even so, these tasks narrow the plausible explanations; they do not reveal an internal acquisition stage with certainty. We should use the evidence to formulate and test instructional hypotheses, not to attach premature labels to students.
If one task can mislead, the solution is not simply to administer three versions of the same task. Triangulation means examining a particular grammatical construction under meaningfully different conditions. Can the learner interpret it? Construct it when prompted? Use it when the message, rather than the form, is the immediate focus? Bachman and Palmer (1996) remind us that language performance is inseparable from task conditions, while Ellis (2009) cautions against treating one task type as a transparent window onto competence.
For French relative clauses, begin with C’est le garçon qui regarde la fille and C’est le garçon que la fille regarde. Ask students to write who is looking at whom in each sentence. Because the nouns stay the same, students must attend more closely to the grammatical relationship. Next, remove the examples and ask for a translation requiring qui or que. Finally, ask for an original description of a photograph using a relative clause.
The three responses need not agree. A student may interpret both sentences correctly yet fail to retrieve que during independent production; another may reproduce a rehearsed relative clause without reliably interpreting unfamiliar ones. That discrepancy is precisely why triangulation is worth doing. Rather than averaging the results into one score, use them to decide what kind of practice should follow.
5. Developmental appropriateness: distinguish scaffolding from readiness
Pienemann (1998)
We should be wary of assuming that a grammatical structure becomes independently available simply because it has been explained and practised. Pienemann’s (1998) Processability Theory draws attention to developmental constraints on certain productive processing procedures.
This is not the same as saying that every error signals developmental unreadiness, or that more practice is futile. It does mean that accurate imitation should not be mistaken for evidence of independent grammatical control.
Take the German subordinate clause. Students first see Ich denke, dass Deutsch interessant ist and replace interessant with nützlich. Then the model disappears and they translate ‘I think that learning languages is important.’ Finally, they formulate an original opinion with dass. A similar progression could use Ich glaube, dass er heute kommt, followed by unfamiliar subordinate clauses in which the learner must independently position the finite verb.
If word order deteriorates as support disappears, we have discovered something about the learner’s current performance, not definitively identified a Processability Theory stage. I would sample several examples across occasions, maintain meaningful input and scaffold output judiciously. Developmental sensitivity means calibrating our expectations to what learners can currently process and produce, while continuing to create opportunities for growth.
6. Cognitive load: accuracy depends partly on processing demands
Sweller (1988); DeKeyser (2007)
A pupil who writes an accurate conditional sentence in a quiet exercise may omit the same ending when arguing a point in conversation. Has the grammar vanished? Not necessarily. During communication, learners must retrieve vocabulary, organise ideas, monitor form and respond to an interlocutor, often at the same time. Sweller’s (1988) account of cognitive load and DeKeyser’s (2007) work on skill development help explain why grammatical performance can become less reliable as demands multiply. Low accuracy under pressure can underestimate what a learner knows, just as high accuracy with scaffolding can overestimate independent control.
Begin with ‘I would travel more if I had time’ and ask for a French translation. Next, remove the model and ask students to write an original hypothetical statement about school. Finally, ask an unexpected hypothetical question orally. The grammatical relationship remains similar, but the demands on lexical selection, independence and real-time processing increase. You could make the comparison more diagnostic by keeping vocabulary constant while changing only the amount of support, before introducing other demands.
A fall in accuracy is a prompt to investigate, not proof that cognitive load caused the error. If performance improves when lexical choice is reduced, vocabulary retrieval may be part of the problem; if errors persist even in a short, familiar sentence, the grammatical construction itself may need more attention. Good formative assessment distinguishes a difficulty with the grammar from a difficulty using that grammar while doing several other things.
7. Form–meaning processing: grammar must carry the answer
VanPatten (1996, 2004)
One of the most persistent traps in grammar assessment is asking a question that students can answer without processing the grammar we intended to test. A student can sometimes arrive at the right interpretation by recognising a familiar noun or a time adverb, while barely attending to the ending on which the teacher’s explanation focused. If the grammar is not needed to obtain the answer, the task offers weak evidence that it was processed.
German case marking offers a useful illustration. Contrast Der Lehrer sieht den Schüler with Den Lehrer sieht der Schüler, then ask who sees whom. In the second sentence, assuming that the first noun must be the agent produces the wrong answer; case marking matters. French provides a parallel example: C’est la fille qui appelle le garçon versus C’est la fille que le garçon appelle. Students identify the caller in each, and you repeat the contrast with new nouns to reduce memorised responding.
If students repeatedly follow word order rather than case marking, I would use structured-input activities that make attention to the relevant grammatical cues necessary for interpretation. Then I would reassess with unfamiliar examples. Recognising that a grammatical form exists is not the same as using it to construct meaning.
8. Actionable feedback: correction is not the endpoint
Lyster & Saito (2010); Hattie & Timperley (2007)
We have all seen the gratifying moment when a student corrects a sentence immediately after feedback. It is progress of a kind, but what kind? The correction may reflect a genuine improvement, a consciously applied rule or simply the recent activation of the teacher’s model. Research on corrective feedback (Lyster & Saito, 2010) and on the conditions under which feedback helps learning (Hattie & Timperley, 2007) encourages a more demanding question: can the learner use the information to improve subsequent performance beyond the original item?
Show Si j’aurais plus d’argent, j’achèterais une voiture. Students correct j’aurais to j’avais, but do not stop there. Remove the sentence and ask for ‘If I had more free time, I would learn another language.’ Then invite an original hypothetical statement about school rules. Revisit the same conditional relationship in a later lesson with different verbs and subjects.
Immediate repair tells us that the student responded to feedback. Successful use in a new sentence suggests transfer under those conditions; delayed retrieval provides stronger evidence that the improvement has endured. If only the original sentence is corrected, I would revisit the form–meaning relationship and vary the practice rather than record the misconception as resolved. Feedback is formative when it changes what learners can subsequently do, not merely what they can correct in front of us.
9. Instructional responsiveness: let evidence change teaching
Black & Wiliam (2009); VanPatten (2004)
A diagnostic result is only the beginning. Black and Wiliam (2009) remind us that evidence becomes formative when it informs what happens next. This is where Principle 9 differs from Principle 3: diagnosis asks what may be going wrong; instructional responsiveness asks what experience is most likely to help. If students cannot interpret a grammatical contrast, more rule-based production may miss the problem. If they understand the meaning but cannot retrieve the form, repeating the comprehension exercise may be equally unhelpful.
Take the Spanish contrast Leía en el jardín / Leí en el jardín.
The imperfect presents the past situation from within, without marking its endpoint; the preterite presents it as bounded. The imperfect does not, by itself, mean ‘used to’. Provide short contexts in which these viewpoints matter, and ask students to choose and justify a form without relying on overt time adverbs. Repeat with Escribía una carta / Escribí una carta. Then remove the models and ask students to express both ‘I was reading when the phone rang’ and ‘I read the letter and replied’.
If students cannot interpret the viewpoint contrast, meaning-focused input is a plausible next step (VanPatten, 2004). If interpretation is secure but endings disappear during writing, scaffold-fading and retrieval may be more useful. And if both are secure in controlled tasks but accuracy falls in discussion, the next practice should vary communicative demands. The same percentage of errors can justify quite different teaching decisions.
10. Retrieval and spacing: do not mistake recency for learning
Roediger & Karpicke (2006); Bjork & Bjork (2011)
A construction practised ten minutes ago is often surprisingly easy to retrieve. That ease can create a comforting but misleading sense of security. Retrieval practice requires learners to bring information to mind, while spacing distributes opportunities to do so over time. Roediger and Karpicke (2006) and Bjork and Bjork (2011) help explain why what is accessible immediately after practice may not remain accessible next week. This principle concerns how we organise opportunities to retrieve and revisit grammar; Principle 11 concerns whether learning subsequently proves durable.
Without notes, ask students to translate ‘I would like to travel more’, ‘I have been learning French for five years’ and ‘If I had more time, I would read more’. Revisit the constructions several days later and again after two or three weeks, changing the vocabulary. You might similarly return to French depuis with the present tense: ‘I have been studying French for three years’, ‘She has been living here since 2022’, then an original statement about a hobby.
Record which constructions remain retrievable and which require renewed support. But remember that translating from English prompts is not the same as selecting the construction spontaneously during communication. Spaced retrieval can both strengthen accessibility and reveal weaknesses; it cannot, on its own, certify automatisation.
11. Durable learning: test delayed transfer, not rehearsed answers
Bjork & Bjork (2011); DeKeyser (2007)
Sometimes a lesson ends with near-perfect responses, only for the same grammar to reappear as a stumbling block a fortnight later. Bjork and Bjork’s (2011) distinction between temporary accessibility and more durable learning is essential here. DeKeyser (2007) also reminds us that practice and developing skill must be considered over time. The crucial question is not only whether a learner can perform today, but whether the construction survives delay and can be applied when the surface features of the task change.
Three weeks after teaching French relative clauses, ask students to translate ‘It’s a film that I watched last weekend.’ Follow with an unfamiliar sentence requiring qui as a subject relative, and then invite students to incorporate a relative clause into an original description. Keep the vocabulary accessible enough that failure cannot be attributed too readily to an unfamiliar noun or verb.
These three tasks distinguish delayed retrieval, selection of a contrasting form and a degree of transfer. A student may succeed on the first and struggle on the third; that pattern matters more than an aggregate score. Revisit the relevant form–meaning contrasts and reassess after a further interval. Delayed success is stronger evidence of retention, though it still does not prove that the grammar has become automatic or implicit.
12. Learner agency: develop self-monitoring without mistaking it for fluency
Sadler (1989); Nicol & Macfarlane-Dick (2006)
Formative assessment should not leave students permanently dependent on the teacher to tell them whether their grammar is acceptable. Sadler (1989) and Nicol and Macfarlane-Dick (2006) make a compelling case for helping learners understand standards, notice discrepancies and act on feedback. Yet self-correction is itself a demanding skill. The student who spots an error during leisurely proofreading may still make it during spontaneous speech, when attention is divided between form and meaning.
Display Si j’étais riche, je voyagerai partout dans le monde. Rather than immediately revealing the correction, ask students to judge the sentence against a criterion: does it express a hypothetical situation, and do the forms reflect that relationship? They correct voyagerai to voyagerais, then construct a new example with the criterion still available. Next remove the prompt and ask them to review a short paragraph for consistency.
What matters is whether the student begins to apply the criterion independently, not simply whether the first correction was right. I would gradually withdraw the prompts and later check how the same construction fares in extended writing and oral interaction. The goal is to develop learners who can increasingly monitor and improve their own language, while recognising that monitoring and automatic use are not identical.
13. Reassessment: verify the instructional response
Black & Wiliam (2009)
A teacher notices a weakness, teaches the point again and sees students complete another worksheet successfully. Has the intervention worked? Perhaps—but the completion of additional practice is not evidence enough. Black and Wiliam (2009) place instructional decisions at the centre of formative assessment, and those decisions themselves need checking. Principle 9 is about choosing a response; Principle 13 is about finding out whether that response was followed by better performance.
Before a lesson on Spanish past viewpoints, present four brief contexts and ask students to select or interpret preterite and imperfect forms. After targeted meaning-focused instruction, use four new but comparably demanding contexts, keeping vocabulary and complexity as similar as possible. Repeat a smaller check the following week. Do not recycle the identical sentences: students may remember answers rather than demonstrate understanding.
A gain is encouraging, but pre- and post-items are rarely perfectly equivalent, and a simple classroom comparison does not prove what caused the improvement. Look at the pattern of errors as well as the score. If learners now interpret the contrast but still cannot produce the forms, the next teaching decision should reflect that distinction. Reassessment closes the formative loop by testing our instructional judgement against fresh evidence.
14. Equity and inclusion: remove irrelevant barriers, not grammar
Messick (1989); CAST (2018)
Fair assessment is sometimes mistaken for making tasks easier. That is not the point. Messick (1989) helps us distinguish the construct we want to assess from irrelevant demands that may distort the result; CAST (2018) offers a broader rationale for accessible learning and assessment. If the objective is to interpret a spoken grammatical contrast, requiring a lengthy written explanation may tell us as much about writing speed and literacy as about grammatical comprehension. We should remove unnecessary barriers without removing the grammar that gives the task its purpose.
Read aloud Si j’avais de l’argent, je voyagerais davantage and Quand j’avais de l’argent, je voyageais davantage. Students respond with HYPOTHETICAL or PAST SITUATION, rather than composing a full explanation. Be precise about what this assesses: si and quand themselves provide meaningful cues, so the task checks interpretation of the construction as a whole, not isolated recognition of the verb morphology. If the latter is the objective, redesign the task to control those cues.
The same principle applies when assessing written agreement: familiar vocabulary and short, clear instructions can reduce unrelated demands, while the agreement contrast remains intact. Later, if the objective becomes extended writing, those additional demands are part of the construct and should not be stripped away. Fairness means making sure the result tells us about the skill we intended to assess, not an accidental obstacle we introduced.
From scores to instructional decisions: ELICIT → DIAGNOSE → RESPOND → VERIFY
ELICIT evidence of a precisely specified skill, with a task that actually requires the targeted grammatical processing. DIAGNOSE the most plausible difficulty, comparing interpretation, retrieval, supported production and communicative use when necessary. RESPOND with the right kind of teaching: structured input, modelling, retrieval, feedback, guided output or communicative practice. VERIFY with new, comparable and sometimes delayed evidence. This cycle is more important than the particular tool used to gather responses.
For example, a class may score 85% on a written conditional exercise yet fail to interpret hypothetical statements in listening. This does not prove a lack of grammar knowledge; it suggests a question about auditory recognition or form–meaning processing. Another class may interpret those statements successfully yet fail to use the conditional in an unrehearsed discussion, suggesting a different bottleneck. The score does not tell us what to do next; the pattern of evidence helps us decide.
Conclusion: assess grammar more intelligently, not simply more frequently
Mini-whiteboards, gap-fills, translations, grammaticality judgements and quizzes are not intrinsically superficial. Each can be useful when the inference is appropriately modest. The danger begins when we treat correct answers as interchangeable evidence of rule knowledge, form–meaning processing, efficient retrieval and spontaneous use. These fourteen principles are overlapping lenses rather than fourteen mutually exclusive psychological constructs: validity governs inference; diagnosticity identifies the likely difficulty; triangulation strengthens the evidence; responsiveness chooses the next step; reassessment checks it; spaced retrieval is a practice, while durable learning is an outcome. None of the sample tasks is presented as a validated diagnostic instrument.
The most useful question is therefore not simply “Have they got it?” but “What can they currently do with this construction, under what conditions, with how much support and effort, and what experience is most likely to move their learning forward?” That is how assessment stops being a record of performance and becomes a tool for advancing grammatical competence.
Selected references
Anderson, J. R. (1982). Acquisition of cognitive skill. Psychological Review, 89(4), 369–406.
Anderson, J. R. (1983). The Architecture of Cognition. Harvard University Press.
Bachman, L. F., & Palmer, A. S. (1996). Language Testing in Practice. Oxford University Press.
Biggs, J. (1996). Enhancing teaching through constructive alignment. Higher Education, 32, 347–364.
Bjork, E. L., & Bjork, R. A. (2011). Making things hard on yourself, but in a good way: Creating desirable difficulties to enhance learning. In M. A. Gernsbacher, R. W. Pew, L. M. Hough, & J. R. Pomerantz (Eds.), Psychology and the Real World: Essays Illustrating Fundamental Contributions to Society. Worth Publishers.
Black, P., & Wiliam, D. (2009). Developing the theory of formative assessment. Educational Assessment, Evaluation and Accountability, 21, 5–31.
CAST (2018). Universal Design for Learning Guidelines, Version 2.2.
DeKeyser, R. M. (1997). Beyond explicit rule learning: Automatizing second language morphosyntax. Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 19(2), 195–221.
DeKeyser, R. M. (Ed.). (2007). Practice in a Second Language: Perspectives from Applied Linguistics and Cognitive Psychology. Cambridge University Press.
Ellis, R. (2005). Measuring implicit and explicit knowledge of a second language: A psychometric study. Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 27, 141–172.
Ellis, R. (2009). Implicit and explicit learning, knowledge and instruction. In Implicit and Explicit Knowledge in Second Language Learning, Testing and Teaching. Multilingual Matters.
Hattie, J., & Timperley, H. (2007). The power of feedback. Review of Educational Research, 77, 81–112.
Lyster, R., & Saito, K. (2010). Oral feedback in classroom SLA: A meta-analysis. Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 32, 265–302.
Messick, S. (1989). Validity. In R. L. Linn (Ed.), Educational Measurement (3rd ed.). Macmillan.
Nicol, D. J., & Macfarlane-Dick, D. (2006). Formative assessment and self-regulated learning: A model and seven principles of good feedback practice. Studies in Higher Education, 31(2), 199–218.
Pienemann, M. (1998). Language Processing and Second Language Development: Processability Theory. John Benjamins.
Roediger, H. L., & Karpicke, J. D. (2006). Test-enhanced learning: Taking memory tests improves long-term retention. Psychological Science, 17, 249–255.
Sadler, D. R. (1989). Formative assessment and instructional systems. Instructional Science, 18, 119–144.
Sweller, J. (1988). Cognitive load during problem solving: Effects on learning. Cognitive Science, 12, 257–285.
VanPatten, B. (1996). Input Processing and Grammar Instruction: Theory and Research. Ablex.
VanPatten, B. (Ed.). (2004). Processing Instruction: Theory, Research, and Commentary. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
When we created the Vocab Trainer we aimed to provide language teachers with a tool that would help students consolidate the target vocabulary in an engaging way whilst scaffolding retrieval gradually and inclusively, allowing the learners to revisit the target chunks of language in multiple meaningful ways across as many language skills and modalities as possible. In this post I intend to provide the pedagogical and scientific rationale for the choice of Vocab Trainer activities as well as their sequencing. Which brings out to the next point: why the sequencing?
Why the order of practice matters as much as the practice itself
One of the fundamental principles of instructed second language acquisition (ISLA) is that exposure to language, however frequent, does not automatically translate into acquisition! Learners need repeated opportunities to process linguistic forms, connect them to meaning, consolidate them in long-term memory and develop increasingly efficient access to them.
However, not all practice is equally effective. Recognising a word when presented with four alternatives is cognitively very different from retrieving it without prompts, reconstructing a sentence or recognising its spoken form in continuous speech. These activities place different demands on attention, working memory, lexical access and retrieval.
This distinction is important because, although vocabulary knowledge develops incrementally, the way we sequence learning activities can either support or undermine that development. Asking beginners to produce language they can barely recognise may overload them, whilst repeatedly presenting familiar words in recognition tasks may create an illusion of mastery.
The twelve activities in The Language Gym Vocab Trainer provide an opportunity to examine how different forms of practice can be organised into a progression from initial familiarisation to increasingly demanding retrieval.
The pedagogical rationale behind the twelve activities
1. Vocab List — Establishing the initial form–meaning connection
Before learners can retrieve a word, they must first establish a representation of its form and meaning. A vocabulary list provides an initial reference point, allowing learners to familiarise themselves with target items and begin establishing lexical associations. From a cognitive perspective, this stage helps reduce the demands of subsequent tasks by making unfamiliar forms more accessible. However, simply reading a list is unlikely to produce durable learning without subsequent processing and retrieval.
Research: Nation (2001); Webb (2007).
2. Self Study — Strengthening initial encoding
Self-study provides an opportunity to revisit target vocabulary at an individual pace, concentrating on items that are not yet securely known.
Repeated encounters can strengthen familiarity with lexical forms and meanings, particularly when learners actively test themselves rather than merely reread material. This distinction matters because repeated exposure and successful retrieval do not have identical effects on long-term retention.
3. One In Four (Reading) — Developing lexical discrimination
Selecting the correct response from several alternatives requires learners to distinguish between competing linguistic representations.
Unlike simple exposure, discrimination tasks require learners to attend to relevant differences in form or meaning. Where distractors are carefully constructed, such activities can help refine lexical knowledge and discourage indiscriminate guessing.
However, recognition with alternatives is generally less demanding than unaided recall, which makes it particularly suitable during earlier stages of learning.
4. Sentence Puzzle — Processing syntax and reconstructing meaning
Reconstructing sentences from constituent elements requires learners to attend to word order, grammatical relationships and the interaction between lexical items.
This is pedagogically important because knowing individual words does not guarantee the ability to combine them into grammatically acceptable sentences.
Sentence reconstruction can encourage learners to process language beyond isolated vocabulary, drawing attention to syntactic patterns and recurring constructions. Its effectiveness is enhanced when learners must consider meaning and grammatical relationships rather than simply exploit superficial clues.
Research: Swain (1995); Ellis (2003).
5. Match Up — Consolidating form–meaning associations
Matching activities require learners to establish connections between lexical forms and their meanings.
Although matching is a relatively low-demand recognition task, it can be valuable during initial learning because it allows repeated processing without requiring learners to generate unfamiliar forms independently.
Its principal limitation is that recognition does not necessarily demonstrate productive knowledge. Consequently, matching is best treated as preparation for more demanding retrieval rather than evidence that vocabulary has been mastered.
One of the difficulties facing language learners is identifying where one word ends and another begins, particularly when familiar items appear in continuous sequences.
Break the Flow directs attention towards identifying boundaries between linguistic units.
In written form, this can reinforce orthographic word recognition and awareness of familiar lexical sequences. If the task also involves connected speech, it can support the development of auditory segmentation skills, which are essential for successful listening comprehension.
These two applications should nevertheless be distinguished: segmenting written strings is not equivalent to segmenting natural speech.
Multiple-choice tasks require learners to select an appropriate response from competing alternatives, as mentioned above. The reason why we added listening multiple choice is obvious: recognizing familiar words aurally is very different from recognizing them in print. At this stage in the sequence, we want to map sound to meaning.
Research: Nation (2001); Roediger & Marsh (2005). Field (2009).
8. Gapfill Race — Promoting cued retrieval
Gap-filling tasks can increase retrieval demands by requiring learners to reconstruct missing linguistic material.
Unlike matching or multiple choice, learners may need to generate a response from partial contextual or orthographic information.
This can strengthen access to lexical forms, provided the gaps require genuine recall rather than allowing answers to be guessed from obvious clues.
The competitive element may increase engagement, but speed should not be prioritised at the expense of accuracy, especially when learners are still developing stable representations.
Anagrams require learners to reconstruct words from scrambled letters, directing attention towards spelling and the internal structure of lexical forms.
This can be particularly useful in languages where learners struggle to remember letter sequences or distinguish visually similar words.
However, anagrams primarily involve orthographic reconstruction. They do not necessarily require learners to retrieve meaning, and their contribution to broader communicative competence is therefore limited unless integrated with other activities.
Research: Ehri (2005); Nation (2001).
10. Dictation — Strengthening sound–form mapping
Dictation requires learners to process spoken input and reconstruct its written representation.
This involves several interconnected processes: phonological discrimination, lexical recognition, segmentation, temporary retention and orthographic encoding.
For learners whose listening difficulties arise partly from weak bottom-up processing, dictation can provide useful diagnostic and remedial practice.
Importantly, its value extends beyond spelling: errors can reveal difficulties with sound recognition, word boundaries and grammatical endings.
Research: Field (2008); Vandergrift & Goh (2012).
11. Beat the Robot — Retrieval under increasing time pressure
Where learners must produce previously encountered language against a time constraint, the activity can place demands on retrieval speed as well as accuracy.
Repeated successful retrieval may contribute to faster lexical access, an important component of fluent language performance.
However, speed alone does not demonstrate automaticity. Learners must first develop sufficiently accurate representations, and premature time pressure can encourage guessing or reinforce errors.
This type of activity is therefore better suited to consolidation than initial exposure.
Translation from the first language into the target language can require learners to retrieve lexical items and grammatical constructions without being presented with their complete target-language forms.
This makes it potentially more demanding than recognition-based activities, particularly when learners must reconstruct entire sentences.
Translation can also reveal gaps in productive knowledge that remain hidden during reading or multiple-choice tasks.
Its value is greatest when learners receive feedback and subsequently reuse the target language in meaningful contexts. Translation into the first language, by contrast, primarily assesses receptive knowledge.
The twelve activities need not be completed in the order in which they appear on the screen. Indeed, a pedagogically coherent sequence should reflect learners’ existing knowledge, the difficulty of the target material and the intended learning outcomes.
The rationale is to begin with substantial support and progressively reduce that support as learners develop more secure lexical representations.
This progression is consistent with principles of scaffolding, skill acquisition and retrieval-based learning. However, it should not be interpreted as an experimentally validated sequence or a rigid hierarchy of difficulty. Some learners may benefit from attempting retrieval earlier, while others may require additional recognition practice before proceeding.
Indeed, research suggests that retrieval practice combined with spacing and feedback can improve L2 vocabulary retention, although the optimal distribution and difficulty of practice depend on several factors. <Cite refs={[“turn304576search7″,”turn304576search9″,”turn304576search2”]}/>
Why this sequence works across a teaching unit
The same activities can fulfil different functions depending on when they are deployed.
Before listening or reading, recognition and familiarisation tasks can activate relevant vocabulary and reduce some of the demands associated with unfamiliar input. Following receptive work, reconstruction and retrieval tasks can encourage learners to revisit and consolidate the language encountered.
As homework, the activities provide opportunities for independent practice, while as lesson starters they can support spaced retrieval of previously taught material.
The important point is that the cognitive demands of the task should match the instructional purpose. A recognition activity may be appropriate before a challenging listening passage, whereas productive translation may be more useful after several encounters with the target language.
Furthermore, teachers should not assume that increasing task difficulty necessarily produces better learning. The Involvement Load Hypothesis (Laufer & Hulstijn, 2001) suggests that tasks involving greater cognitive engagement can promote vocabulary retention, but subsequent research also highlights the importance of task design and the particular dimensions of vocabulary knowledge being developed. <Cite refs={[“turn304576search10″,”turn304576search3”]}/>
Concluding remarks: From successful performance to durable learning
Perhaps the most important distinction teachers should make is between successful task completion and genuine learning.
A student who correctly matches ten words to their meanings has demonstrated recognition under supported conditions. Whether those same words can be retrieved independently a week later is another matter altogether.
This is why varied practice, systematic recycling, feedback and delayed retrieval are so important. The goal should not be to maximise immediate scores or to have students complete as many activities as possible, but to ensure that the target language becomes progressively more accessible, accurate and durable.
The twelve activities in The Language Gym Vocab Trainer can support that process, provided teachers select and sequence them purposefully rather than treating them as interchangeable games.
Ultimately, it is not the number of activities learners complete that matters most, but the quality of the processing they engage in, the success of their retrieval attempts and the durability of what they remember.
Selected references
Cutler, A. (2012). Native Listening: Language Experience and the Recognition of Spoken Words. MIT Press.
DeKeyser, R. M. (Ed.). (2007). *Practice in a Second Language: Perspectives
One of the questions we don’t often ask ourselves as language teachers is what we actually mean by success. We spend considerable time discussing attainment, progress, examination performance, linguistic accuracy and fluency, yet we rarely devote enough attention in my experience to the possibility that some of the most important outcomes of language learning may not be adequately captured by any of these indicators.
Two publications by Suzanne Graham (University of Reading) provide a useful starting point for reflecting on this issue: her chapter Aptitude or motivation: Which is the better predictor of successful language learning? (2022) and her article Self-efficacy and language learning – what it is and what it isn’t (2022).
Although neither publication is primarily concerned with redefining educational success, both raise questions which, in my view, have important implications for how we conceptualise achievement in the modern languages classroom.
What does Graham tell us?
One of the central messages emerging from Graham’s work is that successful language learning cannot be explained simply in terms of linguistic aptitude or motivation considered in isolation. Rather, achievement emerges from the interaction of several factors, including learners’ beliefs about their capabilities, their previous experiences, the opportunities they have to experience success and the educational environments in which learning takes place.
Of particular interest is Graham’s discussion of self-efficacy, which, drawing on Bandura’s social cognitive theory, refers to learners’ beliefs about their ability to perform specific tasks successfully. Importantly, self-efficacy is not synonymous with general confidence, self-esteem or motivation, although these constructs may interact.
A learner may achieve high examination grades while remaining convinced that they cannot cope with an unscripted conversation in the target language. Conversely, another learner whose linguistic performance is less impressive may nevertheless have developed sufficient self-efficacy to attempt communication, tolerate uncertainty, persevere through difficulties and take risks.
This distinction is particularly important because what learners can do and what they believe they can do are not necessarily the same thing.
It also reminds us that success in the language classroom is not simply a matter of accumulating linguistic knowledge. It involves developing the belief that such knowledge can be mobilised effectively when the situation demands it.
My take: success is multidimensional
What I find particularly valuable about Graham’s work is that it challenges us to think beyond simplistic accounts of achievement which attribute success predominantly to ability, effort or motivation, without sufficiently considering the reciprocal relationships between these variables and learners’ experiences.
However, I would extend the argument further: in my view, success in language learning should be understood not only in terms of linguistic attainment, but also in terms of the positive changes that learning brings about in the individual.
Consider, for example, a student who enters secondary school convinced that languages are not for them, perhaps because they have struggled academically in the past or because they have internalised the belief that some people simply do not possess a ‘language brain’. Three years later, that same student may still be performing below the class average, but they may have developed a genuine interest in other cultures, acquired the confidence to initiate basic conversations with speakers of another language and, crucially, begun to see themselves as someone capable of learning.
Has that student been successful? I would argue that they have, even if their examination results do not fully reflect the magnitude of that transformation. Why? because those achievements may be more consequential for their future lives than a grade 9 at French, Spanish or German GCSE.
Equally, a student who achieves an excellent GCSE grade but emerges from the experience disliking languages, fearing mistakes and determined never to study another language again presents us with a rather different picture of success, one which deserves considerably more critical scrutiny than it typically receives.
What does this mean for teaching and assessment?
None of this should be interpreted as an argument for lowering academic expectations, abandoning rigorous assessment or replacing linguistic competence with loosely defined notions of personal development. Accuracy, fluency, automaticity and the ability to comprehend and produce increasingly complex language remain fundamental educational goals, and any attempt to marginalise them would be misguided.
Indeed, there is a potential danger in celebrating confidence or enjoyment without ensuring that learners are actually acquiring the knowledge and skills required to communicate successfully. Confidence unsupported by competence is unlikely to remain sustainable when learners encounter genuine communicative challenges.
This is where I believe Graham’s discussion of self-efficacy becomes especially relevant to classroom practice.
If we want students to develop a robust belief in their ability to use another language, we must provide them with repeated, credible experiences of successful performance. In other words, we cannot simply tell learners that they are capable; we must design instruction that enables them to experience that capability for themselves.
From an instructed second language acquisition perspective, this means carefully sequencing learning, providing extensive modelling and scaffolded practice, gradually increasing task demands and creating opportunities for learners to recognise their own progress before expecting them to perform independently.
It also means that our assessment practices should not merely identify what students cannot yet do, but help them recognise what they can now accomplish that was previously beyond their reach.
The development of competence and the development of self-efficacy should therefore be mutually reinforcing educational objectives, rather than competing priorities.
A final reflection
After many years working with teachers and learners, I have become increasingly convinced that some of our greatest achievements as educators are not necessarily reflected in the highest examination grades or the most impressive displays of linguistic proficiency.
Sometimes, the student who moves from silence to participation, from avoidance to willingness, from fear of failure to a readiness to try, has travelled a greater educational distance than the student who progresses effortlessly from an already advantageous starting point.
This does not make linguistic achievement any less important. It simply reminds us that the educational value of language learning cannot be reduced to what is easiest to measure.
And perhaps one of the most meaningful questions we should ask ourselves at the end of a course is not merely how much language our students have acquired, but how their experience of learning another language has changed their perception of what they are capable of achieving.
Because, ultimately, a student who leaves our classroom believing that they can learn, communicate, persevere and engage with a world beyond their own linguistic and cultural boundaries may have gained something whose value extends far beyond any examination certificate.
References
Graham, S. (2022). Aptitude or motivation: Which is the better predictor of successful language learning? In E. Macaro & R. Woore (Eds.), Debates in Second Language Education (pp. 106–121). Routledge.
Graham, S. (2022). Self-efficacy and language learning – what it is and what it isn’t. The Language Learning Journal, 50(2), 186–207.
Bandura, A. (1997). Self-efficacy: The Exercise of Control. W. H. Freeman.
After years of researching, writing about and teaching listening, here are ten principles which, in my view, should underpin effective listening instruction in the language classroom.
1. Teach listening, don’t just test it.
Playing a recording, asking comprehension questions and checking answers tells us what learners have understood, but does relatively little, on its own, to develop the processes that make comprehension possible. We need to move beyond a predominantly product-oriented approach towards one that explicitly develops listening processes, including decoding, segmentation and meaning construction (Field, 2008; Vandergrift & Goh, 2012).
2. Give bottom-up processing the attention it deserves.
Learners cannot reliably understand what they cannot accurately perceive. If they struggle to discriminate phonemes, identify word boundaries or recognise familiar words in connected speech, contextual guessing will only take them so far. Bottom-up training should therefore be a systematic component of listening instruction, alongside top-down processing and metacognitive strategies (Vandergrift, 2004; Siegel & Siegel, 2015). Picture 1, below, provides a breakdown of the bottom-up processing skills involving in decoding a sentence, i.e. Phoneme Categorization, Syllable and Prosodic Chunking, Lexical Retrieval, Morphological and Syntactic parsing. The brain has approximately two seconds to make sense of a sentence applying the above skills.
Picture 1 – The listening process
3. Use Listening as Modelling to drive acquisition.
Listening should not merely develop receptive comprehension; it should also provide rich, comprehensible and carefully patterned input from which learners can gradually build more robust phonological, lexical and grammatical representations. In EPI, Listening as Modelling exploits repeated exposure to high-frequency constructions to prepare learners for subsequent speaking and writing (VanPatten, 1996; Ellis, 2002; Conti & Smith, 2019).
4. Exploit narrow listening and controlled variation.
Rather than constantly exposing beginners to unrelated recordings containing unfamiliar language, provide multiple short texts built around recurring vocabulary, chunks and grammatical patterns, varying selected elements while keeping much of the linguistic content familiar. This increases opportunities for repeated processing, strengthens form–meaning connections and may facilitate faster recognition (Krashen, 1996; Ellis, 2002; Webb & Nation, 2017).
Picture 2 – A set of narrow-listening texts
5. Teach connected speech, segmentation and prosody explicitly.
One of the greatest challenges facing L2 listeners is that spoken language does not arrive neatly divided into words. Coarticulation, reduction, rhythm, stress and intonation can make even familiar vocabulary difficult to recognise. Explicitly drawing attention to these features through focused discrimination, segmentation and chunking activities can help learners develop more efficient perceptual processing (Cutler, 2012; Field, 2008).
6. Make micro-listening a regular classroom staple.
Instead of relying predominantly on lengthy recordings, use short stretches of speech to target specific processing difficulties. Tasks involving phoneme discrimination, word-boundary identification, reduced forms, lexical recognition and short dictations can provide concentrated practice without overwhelming learners’ limited processing capacity. Research supports the inclusion of focused bottom-up activities in listening instruction (Field, 2008; Siegel & Siegel, 2015).
7. Promote thorough processing, not just gist comprehension.
Understanding the general message is important, but learners also need to attend to the linguistic detail that determines meaning: negation, verb endings, pronouns, time markers and syntactic relationships. Activities such as Faulty Transcript, Faulty Translation and partial dictation can direct attention towards features that learners might otherwise overlook, encouraging more precise form–meaning mapping (Schmidt, 1990; VanPatten, 1996; Field, 2008).
8. Recycle listening input intelligently.
Replaying a recording is not necessarily the same as providing meaningful additional practice. Each encounter should ideally serve a different processing purpose, progressing, for example, from global understanding to detailed comprehension, decoding, grammatical noticing and reconstruction. Such purposeful recycling is consistent with research on repeated processing, retrieval and skill development, although the precise sequence should reflect learners’ needs (DeKeyser, 2007; Nation, 2013; Vandergrift & Goh, 2012).
9. Diagnose listening difficulties before attempting remediation.
A wrong answer does not tell us why comprehension failed. Was the problem unfamiliar vocabulary, inaccurate phonological representations, segmentation, syntactic parsing, excessive processing demands or an incorrect inference? Diagnostic listening activities, including transcript comparison and targeted re-listening, can help teachers identify likely sources of breakdown and provide more focused intervention (Graham, 2006; Field, 2008; Vandergrift & Goh, 2012).
10. Build automaticity, independence and transfer.
The ultimate aim is not for learners to understand recordings only when supported by transcripts, visuals or repeated teacher intervention, but to process increasingly unfamiliar speech accurately and efficiently in real time. Scaffolding should therefore be gradually withdrawn as recognition becomes more automatic, while learners encounter different speakers, contexts and communicative demands (Segalowitz, 2010; DeKeyser, 2007; Vandergrift & Goh, 2012).
The bottom line
For too long, listening has been treated primarily as a comprehension-testing exercise rather than a skill requiring systematic development and a powerful vehicle for language acquisition. Effective listening instruction must do both: teach learners how to process spoken language while using carefully designed input to build the linguistic knowledge that makes comprehension increasingly effortless.
These principles have informed my work on EPI, Listening as Modelling and Breaking the Sound Barrier: teaching learners how to listen (Conti and Smith, 2019), as well as the numerous articles on listening I have published over the last decade on www.gianfrancoconti.com.
Selected Bibliography
1. Cutler, A. (2012). Native listening: Language experience and the recognition of spoken words. MIT Press.
2. DeKeyser, R. M. (Ed.). (2007). Practice in a second language: Perspectives from applied linguistics and cognitive psychology. Cambridge University Press.
3. Ellis, N. C. (2002). Frequency effects in language processing: A review with implications for theories of implicit and explicit language acquisition. Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 24(2), 143–188.
4. Field, J. (2008). Listening in the language classroom. Cambridge University Press. Cambridge Assets+1
5. Field, J. (2008). Revising segmentation hypotheses in first and second language listening. System, 36(1), 35–51.
6. Goh, C. C. M. (2008). Metacognitive instruction for second language listening development: Theory, practice and research implications. RELC Journal, 39(2), 188–213.
7. Graham, S. (2006). Listening comprehension: The learners’ perspective. System, 34(2), 165–182. ERIC+1
8. Krashen, S. D. (1996). The case for narrow listening. System, 24(1), 97–100.
9. Schmidt, R. W. (1990). The role of consciousness in second language learning. Applied Linguistics, 11(2), 129–158.
10. Segalowitz, N. (2010). Cognitive bases of second language fluency. Routledge.
11. Siegel, J., & Siegel, A. (2015). Getting to the bottom of L2 listening instruction: Making a case for bottom-up activities. Studies in Second Language Learning and Teaching, 5(4), 637–662. PRESSto
12. Vandergrift, L. (2004). Listening to learn or learning to listen? Annual Review of Applied Linguistics, 24, 3–25.
13. Vandergrift, L., & Goh, C. C. M. (2012). Teaching and learning second language listening: Metacognition in action. Routledge. Google Books+1
14. VanPatten, B. (1996). Input processing and grammar instruction: Theory and research. Ablex.
15. Webb, S., & Nation, P. (2017). How vocabulary is learned. Oxford University Press.
Why checking grammatical understanding is not the same as assessing grammatical learning
Introduction
One of the most worrying trends in MFL education, in my view, is the growing tendency to confuse successful performance in classroom assessment tasks with evidence of language acquisition, as though students correctly answering a diagnostic multiple-choice question, completing a translation, identifying a grammatical error or explaining a rule necessarily meant that they had ‘got it’.But have they? And, more importantly, what exactly have they got?
This is precisely the problem I see in a recent blog post, “Do They Really Get It? Rethinking Formative Assessment and How to C4U (Part 1)”, which advocates mini-whiteboards, diagnostic questions, retrieval practice, interleaving and corrective feedback as ways of checking students’ understanding, yet pays insufficient attention to a fundamental distinction that decades of research in instructed second-language acquisition (ISLA) have highlighted: knowing a grammatical rule, recognising its correct application and being able to process and use it accurately, efficiently and automatically are very different things.
And surely this is a rather serious omission in an article specifically concerned with formative assessment? After all, if the whole purpose of formative assessment is to generate evidence that informs our next instructional decisions, what happens when we misunderstand what that evidence actually demonstrates? What happens when we take a correct answer as proof of learning, when all it may demonstrate is that a student can perform successfully under the very specific conditions created by the task?
Consider a student who correctly identifies elle est allée in a multiple-choice question but continues to produce elle a allé in spontaneous speech, or another who can confidently explain German verb-final word order after weil yet repeatedly gets it wrong in conversation. Or take a student who scores highly on a French tense quiz but cannot distinguish the same tenses when listening two connected speech… Has that student really ‘got it’? Or have we simply assessed the aspects of grammatical knowledge that are easiest to test, while leaving the more demanding aspects of linguistic processing and production largely untouched?
These are not minor discrepancies. They expose the limitations of such assessment tasks as indicators of developing linguistic competence, limitations which become particularly problematic when teachers interpret successful performance as evidence that a construction has been acquired and that they can safely move on.
And this brings me to a wider concern, one that I have raised repeatedly over the years: the increasingly uncritical transfer of techniques and practices from general education into MFL, often accompanied by the fashionable label ‘evidence-informed’, as though findings from cognitive psychology and general educational research could simply be transplanted into language teaching without first considering what decades of ISLA research tell us about input processing, form–meaning connections, developmental sequences and automaticity.
The danger, of course, is that we create an illusion of learning, whereby students appear successful because they perform well on the tasks we set, while crucial aspects of their developing linguistic competence remain unassessed. And if that happens, what are the consequences? Teachers may move on prematurely, misdiagnose persistent grammatical errors, devote precious classroom time to explaining rules students already know, or neglect the listening, reading and spontaneous production skills that students will eventually need when confronted with unfamiliar language in their GCSE examinations.
Because let’s not forget that, when a student sits a GCSE listening paper, there is no teacher pausing after every sentence to ask a diagnostic question, no mini-whiteboard on which to select the correct verb ending, and no helpful prompt reminding them which tense to retrieve. They have to process the language as it unfolds, identify grammatical distinctions under time pressure and construct meaning from what they hear… and if our formative assessment has consistently failed to reveal weaknesses in those processes, how well have we actually prepared them?
Badly interpreted formative assessment doesn’t merely fail to identify learning gaps; it can actively contribute to poor instructional decisions, precisely because what teachers believe students have mastered inevitably influences what they choose to teach, practise, recycle or abandon.
And that is why I find the author’s treatment of the issue problematic. The question is not whether mini-whiteboards, retrieval quizzes or diagnostic questions are useful, but whether the evidence they generate actually justifies the conclusions teachers draw from it. Because if we cannot distinguish between remembering a rule, recognising a form, processing it for meaning and deploying it spontaneously, then what exactly are we checking for understanding… and, more importantly, whose understanding of language acquisition really needs checking?
1. Knowing a rule is NOT the same as acquiring it
Take German weil clauses, for example, which students may have practised repeatedly through rule explanations, sentence corrections and mini-whiteboard exercises, and imagine asking a Year 10 class where the verb goes after weil. “At the end, Sir!” they confidently reply, and when you subsequently give them five sentences containing word-order errors, most correct them without difficulty. So far, so good… but what happens when, a few minutes later, you ask those same students to explain spontaneously why they dislike school?
Ich mag die Schule nicht, weil es ist langweilig.
Sound familiar? And if it does, should we automatically conclude that they haven’t understood the rule, that we need to explain it again, or that another round of corrective questions will somehow resolve the problem?
As I have often notices throughout my career, the issue is that students may know the rule perfectly well, and may even be able to explain and apply it successfully when their attention is explicitly directed towards it, while still lacking the processing efficiency required to retrieve and deploy the construction when simultaneously thinking about what they want to say, selecting vocabulary and organising their utterance.
Knowing ABOUT a construction and being able to USE it automatically are two very different things, as research on skill acquisition and automaticity reminds us (DeKeyser & Criado, 2013), and while explicit explanation may contribute to learning, it cannot be assumed that another explanation followed by another correct mini-whiteboard answer will produce the kind of fluent, independent performance we ultimately want
So, when students repeatedly make the same grammatical mistake despite apparently knowing the rule, shouldn’t we at least consider whether the problem lies not in their understanding but in their ability to process and retrieve the construction efficiently?
2. What about processing grammar for meaning?
Another limitation of formative assessment that concentrates predominantly on translation, correcting errors, choosing endings and explaining rules is that it may tell us relatively little about whether students can actually process grammatical constructions for meaning when listening and reading, which, given the demands of GCSE receptive examinations, is a rather significant omission.
Consider the following French sentences:
Il a mangé.
Il mangeait.
Il mange.
Students may correctly identify the tense of each verb, explain how it is formed and translate the sentences accurately when presented in writing, but… can they distinguish these forms when they hear them in connected speech? Can they interpret the differences in meaning within a narrative, particularly when the context doesn’t make the answer obvious, or are they simply relying on familiar vocabulary and contextual clues while paying little attention to the grammatical morphology itself?
Imagine, for example, that students read a short account of a holiday and answer the comprehension questions correctly because they recognise words such as hier, plage and restaurant. Does that mean they have accurately processed the tense markers, or have they managed to reconstruct the message without really attending to them?
VanPatten’s research on input processing (1996, 2004) reminds us that learners often prioritise lexical information over grammatical morphology, particularly when the latter contributes relatively little additional meaning, while VanPatten and Oikkenon (1996) demonstrated the value of structured input activities in developing grammatical processing. And this is why I find it problematic when formative assessment of grammar focuses so heavily on whether students can identify, explain or produce forms, while paying insufficient attention to whether they can actually interpret them in meaningful input.
Before asking whether students can produce a grammatical construction, shouldn’t we establish whether they can process it accurately for meaning? And if we don’t assess that ability, how can we know whether students are developing the kind of receptive competence that GCSE listening and reading examinations demand?
3. Correct answers can be very misleading
Diagnostic multiple-choice questions are frequently presented as powerful tools for identifying misconceptions, and rightly so in certain circumstances. However, their diagnostic value depends entirely on what we are trying to establish and, more crucially, what conclusions we draw from students’ responses!
Consider a student who is asked to select the correct sentence from the following alternatives:
Elle a allée.
Elle est allée.
Elle est allé.
The student selects the second option, and we congratulate ourselves because the question has apparently demonstrated that they understand the formation of the perfect tense with aller. But what exactly have we established? That they know the rule? That they remember an example from yesterday’s lesson? That they have successfully eliminated two implausible alternatives? Or simply that they have guessed correctly?
Now ask that same student to describe what their sister did last weekend without prompting, and will elle est allée emerge as readily and accurately? Possibly… but possibly not, which is precisely why a correct answer in a controlled task is evidence of successful performance in THAT task, not proof that the construction has been acquired.
The same problem arises when we interpret errors, because a wrong answer doesn’t automatically mean that the student has misunderstood the rule or that the most appropriate response is to explain it again. Perhaps the construction isn’t sufficiently automatised, perhaps competing forms are interfering with retrieval, perhaps the student is experiencing processing overload, or perhaps they simply need more meaningful exposure and appropriately designed practice.
And herein lies the limitation of diagnostic questions: although they can reveal where performance breaks down, they don’t necessarily tell us why it breaks down, particularly when the same observable error may arise from very different underlying causes.
If formative assessment is supposed to inform our instructional decisions, shouldn’t we be rather more cautious about diagnosing the cause of a problem from a single correct or incorrect answer?
4. Retrieval practice is useful. But WHAT are we retrieving?
Take a familiar translation exercise in which students areasked to translate “Yesterday we went to the beach” into Spanish and correctly produce Ayer fuimos a la playa. A successful retrieval, certainly, but let’s consider what the task actually demands, because the English prompt has already supplied the meaning, the temporal reference and much of the sentence structure, allowing students to concentrate on selecting and assembling the appropriate Spanish forms.
Now ask the same students to recount an unexpected holiday experience, without preparation, while responding to follow-up questions, and will fuimos emerge as readily? Will they select the appropriate tense while simultaneously deciding what to say, retrieving vocabulary and organising their ideas?
Not necessarily, and this is why the distinction between retrieving grammatical forms under controlled conditions and deploying them during communication matters so much.
Research by Nakata and Suzuki (2019), for example, provide evidence that interleaving grammatical exercises can improve delayed retention, while DeKeyser’s work on skill acquisition highlights the importance of appropriately designed practice in developing efficient language use. But neither finding justifies treating successful retrieval in a highly supported task as equivalent to fluent, independent production.
The type of retrieval practice matters, as does the type of performance we use to assess its effects, because while supported translation, sentence completion and grammaticality judgements can all contribute valuable evidence, they cannot, on their own, establish whether students can retrieve and manipulate the same structures when the prompts disappear.
And surely this should influence how we interpret the results of retrieval quizzes? If students consistently perform well on them but struggle to produce three spontaneous sentences, is the problem really that they need more retrieval quizzes, or that we have been assessing a rather narrow form of retrieval while neglecting the more demanding conditions under which language must eventually be used?
5. Grammar acquisition is not simply error elimination
Another concern of mine is the assumption that when students repeatedly make grammatical errors, the logical response is to explain the rule, correct the mistake and retest, as though grammar acquisition were essentially a process of identifying gaps in explicit knowledgeand eliminating them through successive rounds of explanation and correction. Which, of course, is often an utter waste of time!
Don’t get me wrong; sometimes that may be precisely what is needed, but grammar development is considerably more complex, because learners do not simply accumulate rules until their internal grammar is complete; rather, they develop evolving linguistic systems in which certain constructions may remain unstable despite repeated explanations, apparently successful practice and considerable conscious knowledge…
This is precisely what Pienemann’s Processability Theory (1998) helps explain, since learners do not necessarily acquire grammatical structures in the order in which we teach them, and certain constructions require processing procedures that develop in a predictable sequence. Consequently, a student may know a rule, explain it accurately and even apply it successfully in a controlled exercise without necessarily being developmentally ready to deploy the construction spontaneously.
So, when a learner repeatedly produces weil es ist instead of weil es … ist, should we automatically assume that the original explanation was inadequate, that retrieval practice has been insufficient or that another corrective exercise will solve the problem? Or might the error reflect the current state of the learner’s developing grammatical processing system?
Of course, not every persistent error is evidence of developmental unreadiness, and we should be equally cautious about making that diagnosis without appropriate evidence, but Pienemann’s Teachability Hypothesis (1989) reminds us that instruction cannot necessarily override developmental constraints simply because we have explained a structure clearly and tested it repeatedly.
You cannot simply explain or quiz a learner into the next developmental stage, however appealing that possibility might be to teachers under pressure to demonstrate rapid progress.
Corrective feedback can certainly contribute to language development, as Lyster and Saito’s (2010) meta-analysis demonstrates, but its effectiveness does not mean that every error is best addressed through another explanation or another correction task, particularly when the learner already possesses the relevant explicit knowledge.
And if students repeatedly produce weil es ist despite being able to explain verb-final word order perfectly well, might they benefit more from meaningful processing, structured practice and opportunities to develop fluent retrieval than from yet another reminder of a rule they already know?
Explanation + correct answer ≠ acquisition, and until our formative assessment recognises that distinction, we risk responding to developmental and processing problems as though they were simply failures of memory or understanding.
6. The GCSE problem: Are we preparing students for the examination or for our classroom tasks?
And this is where the consequences become particularly serious, because while the limitations of controlled formative assessment may appear relatively harmless during an ordinary Year 10 lesson, they can become painfully obvious when students encounter the demands of GCSE examinations.
Consider a Year 11 student who consistently performs well in grammar retrieval quizzes, sentence translations and error-correction exercises, whose mini-whiteboard answers are usually correct, who can explain the difference between the perfect and imperfect tenses and who knows exactly where the verb goes after weil. Everything looks reassuring, doesn’t it? The teacher has evidence of progress, the student feels confident, and the class appears to be moving steadily towards examination readiness.
But what happens when that same student sits the GCSE?
In listening, they may struggle to distinguish j’ai joué from je jouais because they haven’t developed sufficiently rapid and accurate processing of tense morphology in connected speech; in reading, they may recognise familiar vocabulary yet misinterpret who did what, when or to whom because they overlook grammatical markers; in speaking, they may produce beautifully rehearsed answers but struggle when the examiner asks an unexpected question requiring independent retrieval and manipulation of language; and in writing, they may reproduce memorised structures accurately while finding it difficult to adapt them to an unfamiliar task.
The problem isn’t necessarily that they haven’t learned the grammar, but that their ability to retrieve grammatical knowledge in controlled conditions has developed further than their ability to process and deploy it independently, a discrepancy which research on input processing (VanPatten, 1996, 2004), skill acquisition (DeKeyser, 2013) and developmental constraints (Pienemann, 1998) gives us good reasons to anticipate.
And this is why formative assessment matters so much, because if our assessment repeatedly tells us that students have ‘got it’ simply because they can answer a diagnostic question, complete a translation or correct a grammatical error, we may seriously overestimate their examination readiness, move on prematurely and devote insufficient time to precisely those abilities that will determine how successfully they cope with unfamiliar language under pressure.
Worse still, students themselves may develop a false sense of confidence, believing that their success in classroom grammar tasks means they are well prepared, only to discover in the examination that the language they could manipulate so successfully with prompts and familiar examples is considerably harder to understand and use when those supports disappear.
And surely this is the real danger of misinterpreting formative assessment evidence? Not that students occasionally get a question wrong, but that teachers may be systematically reassured by the wrong kinds of success, thereby overlooking weaknesses in listening discrimination, grammatical processing, independent retrieval and spontaneous production until those weaknesses become visible in the GCSE examination itself.
Good formative assessment should expose these gaps BEFORE the GCSE examination does, which means assessing not simply whether students remember grammatical forms, but whether they can process and use them under conditions that increasingly resemble the demands of the examination.
Otherwise, are we really preparing students for GCSE, or merely making them increasingly proficient at the particular classroom tasks through which we have chosen to measure their progress?
Table 1. What classroom assessment tasks reveal, what they may conceal, and why the distinction matters for GCSE success.
Activity
What it assesses
What you it may conceal
GCSE consequence
Vocabulary translation
Lexical recall
Difficulty recognising words in connected speech
Listening weaknesses
Sentence translation
Supported grammatical retrieval
Limited independent production
Speaking and writing weaknesses
Multiple-choice grammar
Recognition of correct forms
Inability to process or produce them independently
False confidence
Spot-the-mistake
Explicit error recognition
Lack of automatic grammatical control
Persistent errors
Rule explanation
Declarative knowledge
Inability to apply rules under pressure
Poor spontaneous performance
Retrieval quizzes
Recall under controlled conditions
Weak transfer to communication
Overestimated readiness
Interleaving
Discrimination and retrieval across structures
Difficulty processing structures in real time
Receptive weaknesses
Feedback and redrafting
Ability to improve supported output
Inability to reproduce improvements independently
Writing weaknesses
Short oral GCSE prompts
Prepared or cued production
Limited spontaneity and flexibility
Speaking weaknesses
7. So what should we actually be assessing?
If the problem lies not necessarily in the techniques themselves but in what we infer from their results, then surely the answer is to broaden the range of evidence we collect, ensuring that our formative assessment addresses the different dimensions of grammatical competence rather than treating them as interchangeable.
Research in instructed second-language acquisition provides good reasons for doing so, with VanPatten and Oikkenon (1996) highlighting the importance of structured input for developing grammatical processing, DeKeyser (2013) emphasising the role of practice in developing efficient language skills, Nakata and Suzuki (2019) providing evidence for the benefits of interleaving on delayed retention, and Lyster and Saito (2010) demonstrating that corrective feedback can contribute to language development.
So what might acquisition-informed formative assessment actually look like in a busy MFL classroom, particularly when teachers have limited preparation time and need techniques that can be implemented quickly without producing yet another elaborate worksheet?
I would suggest assessing at least five dimensions, using activities that require virtually no preparation and, importantly, making intelligent use of mini-whiteboards wherever they can provide useful evidence.
1. Form–meaning processing: Can students actually understand the grammar?
Before asking students to produce a construction, shouldn’t we establish whether they can interpret it accurately when listening and reading, particularly given what VanPatten’s input-processing research tells us about learners’ tendency to prioritise lexical information over grammatical morphology?
Minimal-prep activity: Listen and choose
Say two French sentences:
A. Quand j’étais petit, je jouais au foot.
B. Hier, j’ai joué au foot.
Then ask students which sentence describes a habitual activity in the past, requiring them to write A or B on their mini-whiteboards and reveal their answers simultaneously, before repeating the task with different sentences in which obvious temporal clues have been removed so that students must attend more closely to the grammatical forms.
What are we assessing here? Not whether students remember the rule for forming the imperfect, but whether they can interpret the meaning conveyed by the construction when they hear it, which is a rather different achievement.
The mini-whiteboard, in this case, becomes a tool for assessing form–meaning processing rather than merely checking explicit grammatical knowledge, although we should still be cautious about assuming that success with isolated sentences guarantees equally accurate processing in longer stretches of connected speech.
2. Controlled production: Can students retrieve the construction with limited support?
Once students have encountered and processed a construction, we can assess whether they can retrieve it in a relatively controlled context, while recognising that the amount of support provided will influence the demands of the task and therefore the conclusions we can draw from their performance.
Minimal-prep activity: Complete and transform
Write the following sentence on the board:
Ich mag Deutsch, weil es …
Ask students to complete it on their mini-whiteboards, then change the reason using interessant, before removing the written sentence starter altogether and asking them to produce the entire sentence independently.
By gradually reducing support, we obtain different kinds of evidence about students’ ability to retrieve and manipulate the construction, which is useful given DeKeyser’s (2013) emphasis on appropriately designed practice and the development of increasingly efficient access to linguistic knowledge.
But let’s not exaggerate what this demonstrates, because successful controlled production, however encouraging, is not proof that students can retrieve and use the same construction spontaneously, particularly when the task has explicitly directed their attention towards it.
3. Independent production: Can students use the construction without being told to?
This is where things become particularly interesting, because students who produce accurate grammar when explicitly prompted to use a particular construction may perform rather differently when the prompt disappears and they have to decide for themselves which linguistic resources to deploy.
Minimal-prep activity: Say something about yourself
Instead of asking students to “write a sentence using weil“, ask them why they enjoy or dislike learning German and invite them to give two reasons, allowing a brief thinking period before they write their responses on mini-whiteboards without a displayed model or sentence starter.
Now examine whether they choose to use weil, whether they use it accurately and whether they can formulate their answers without relying on the scaffolding that previously supported their performance; for a more demanding check, ask students to respond orally in pairs and listen to selected exchanges.
This distinction matters because Lyster and Saito’s (2010) meta-analysis found that corrective feedback can produce durable effects on language development, with particularly notable effects on measures requiring learners to construct their own responses.
The question, therefore, is not simply whether students can produce the target construction, but whether they can select and deploy it when the task doesn’t explicitly tell them to, which brings us considerably closer to the kind of independent language use required in GCSE speaking and writing.
4. Retrieval efficiency: Can students retrieve grammar accurately under time pressure?
Accuracy alone tells us relatively little about how efficiently students can retrieve grammatical knowledge, because a learner who takes thirty seconds to construct a correct sentence is demonstrating something rather different from one who can retrieve and assemble the same construction accurately within a few seconds. But how can we assess this efficiently across an entire class, without relying on oral responses that the teacher cannot possibly monitor simultaneously?
Minimal-prep activity: Timed Sentence Challenge
Display a familiar question on the board, such as Warum magst du Deutsch?, and give students five seconds to write a complete answer on their mini-whiteboards, without notes, sentence starters or other prompts. On your signal, everyone raises their boards simultaneously, allowing you to check who has produced an accurate response, who has made grammatical errors and who has failed to complete the sentence within the allotted time. Repeat with different questions and constructions, gradually adjusting the time available to the students’ proficiency level, while ensuring that the time limit remains realistic and does not simply penalise slower writers.
What does this tell us? Certainly more than an untimed grammar quiz about students’ ability to retrieve and assemble language efficiently, particularly when we compare their performance across successive lessons and observe whether accuracy can be maintained as the processing demands increase. However, speeded written retrieval is not the same as oral automaticity, since handwriting speed, spelling and the demands of written formulation also influence performance, which is why we should resist the temptation to interpret rapid, accurate mini-whiteboard responses as proof that students can deploy the same constructions spontaneously in conversation.
And isn’t that precisely the point? Good formative assessment doesn’t simply generate correct answers; it generates evidence whose limitations we understand, so that we can make better-informed instructional decisions rather than mistaking success in one type of task for mastery of the underlying linguistic competence.
5. Durability: Can students still use the grammar weeks later?
Perhaps one of the most neglected dimensions of classroom assessment is durability, because students frequently perform brilliantly immediately after a lesson, particularly when the target construction is fresh in their minds and the task makes it obvious which grammatical form they are expected to retrieve, but what happens three weeks later?
Minimal-prep activity: The unexpected comeback
Three weeks after teaching weil, include a question in an ordinary retrieval starter asking students to explain why they like or dislike one school subject, without mentioning weil, displaying the rule or announcing that subordinate clauses are being revisited.
Students write their answers on mini-whiteboards, allowing you to compare their performance with what you observed previously, before revisiting the same construction a week later through a different topic or communicative context.
Nakata and Suzuki (2019) found that interleaved grammar practice improved performance on a delayed grammaticality judgement test compared with blocked practice, providing support for the benefits of revisiting grammatical knowledge across time, although their findings should not be interpreted as evidence that delayed recognition necessarily entails spontaneous mastery.
If students can only use a construction correctly immediately after practising it, how secure is their learning? And if our formative assessment rarely examines what remains accessible after the immediate instructional context has disappeared, aren’t we at risk of confusing short-term performance with durable learning?
The point
Notice that mini-whiteboards feature in almost every example, which should make it abundantly clear that my criticism is not directed at the technique itself but at the narrow range of evidence that teachers may sometimes collect through it, and at the conclusions they subsequently draw.
Mini-whiteboards can be excellent tools for obtaining rapid, whole-class evidence of grammatical interpretation, controlled retrieval, increasingly independent formulation and delayed retention, provided that the questions are designed to assess those particular dimensions, although they are obviously less suitable for evaluating spontaneous oral fluency, where direct observation is essential.
And none of these checks, taken individually, proves that a construction has been fully acquired, which brings us back to the central issue of assessment validity: does the task actually provide evidence of the aspect of grammatical competence we claim to be assessing?
Processability Theory (Pienemann, 1998) adds another important consideration, since a learner may successfully apply a grammatical rule in a controlled task without having developed the processing procedures required for spontaneous production, reminding us that persistent errors should be interpreted cautiously rather than automatically treated as evidence that another explanation or quiz is needed.
So, by all means, use mini-whiteboards, diagnostic questions, retrieval quizzes and corrective feedback, but let’s be considerably clearer about what they tell us, because recognising grammar, retrieving grammar, using grammar spontaneously and using it automatically are not interchangeable achievements, and treating them as though they were risks making us increasingly proficient at measuring what is easiest to test while neglecting what students actually need to learn.
Concluding remarks
This is not the first time I have noticed what I consider to be an insufficiently critical transfer of findings and practices from general education into MFL in several MFL bloggers and commentators, and I suspect that this tendency reflects, at least partly, a superficial engagement with research in instructed second-language acquisition, combined with an eagerness to ride the latest wave of educational trends.
Retrieval practice, cognitive load, interleaving, mini-whiteboards, Rosenshine’s principles… all potentially valuable, certainly, but since when did the popularity of a technique in general education automatically make it appropriate for language learning, and why should we accept recommendations labelled ‘evidence-informed’ when the evidence being invoked has not been adequately considered alongside what we know about the distinctive processes involved in acquiring another language?
And before anyone interprets this as an ad hominem attack, let me be clear that my criticism is directed at a widespread misconception in MFL discourse, not at an individual, because the problem extends well beyond one blog post or one commentator and deserves serious scrutiny precisely because of its implications for classroom practice.
Those implications are far from trivial, particularly when we consider what happens to students at GCSE, because the danger is not that retrieval quizzes or mini-whiteboards are inherently harmful, but that overreliance on the evidence they generate can create a misleading picture of linguistic competence, encouraging teachers to move on prematurely, neglect essential processing skills and discover weaknesses only when students are confronted with the demands of an examination.
A class may appear successful because students consistently produce correct answers in controlled tasks, yet remain poorly equipped to process unfamiliar language in real time, interpret grammatical distinctions in connected speech or retrieve and manipulate structures independently when the scaffolding disappears… and if teachers have interpreted those correct answers as evidence of acquisition, what incentive have they had to address the weaknesses that their assessment never revealed?
This is why I would argue that poorly interpreted formative assessment is not simply an assessment problem but potentially a curriculum and instructional problem, because what teachers believe students have mastered inevitably influences what they choose to teach, practise, recycle or abandon, with consequences that may only become apparent when students struggle in their GCSE listening, reading, speaking and writing examinations.
And surely this is what should concern us most? Not whether our lessons feature the latest fashionable assessment technique, whether students can confidently explain a grammatical rule or whether every mini-whiteboard displays the correct answer, but whether the evidence we collect actually tells us something meaningful about the linguistic competence our students are developing.
None of this requires rejecting cognitive psychology or dismissing the techniques Bastow advocates, but being genuinely evidence-informed requires considerably more than citing fashionable educational research and applying its recommendations to MFL, because it also demands an understanding of how those findings interact with decades of ISLA research on input processing, developmental readiness, form–meaning connections, skill acquisition and automaticity.
And if we fail to make those distinctions, who ultimately pays the price? Not the commentators promoting the techniques, nor the teachers who have been reassured by apparently impressive classroom performance, but the students who discover, when faced with unfamiliar language under examination conditions, that knowing the rules and passing the quizzes was never quite the same as being able to understand and use the language.
Students should not pay the price for our failure to distinguish between grammatical knowledge and grammatical acquisition, particularly when that failure may leave them less prepared for the very examinations towards which so much of their learning has been directed.
So perhaps the most important question isn’t whether students can demonstrate that they remember what we taught them, but whether they can actually understand and use the language when the prompts disappear, the scaffolding is removed and the demands of real-time processing take over…If our formative assessment cannot distinguish between the two, we are not just misleading ourselves about how much students have learned; we risk failing the very students we claim to be helping.
Selected references
DeKeyser, R. (2013). Automatization, Skill Acquisition, and Practice in Second Language Acquisition.
DeKeyser, R. & Criado, R. (2013). Automatization, Skill Acquisition, and Practice in Second Language Acquisition.
Lyster, R. & Saito, K. (2010). Oral Feedback in Classroom SLA: A Meta-Analysis.Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 32, 265–302.
Nakata, T. & Suzuki, Y. (2019). Mixing Grammar Exercises Facilitates Long-Term Retention.The Modern Language Journal, 103, 629–647.
Pienemann, M. (1989). Is Language Teachable? Psycholinguistic Experiments and Hypotheses.Applied Linguistics, 10, 52–79.
Pienemann, M. (1998). Language Processing and Second Language Development: Processability Theory. John Benjamins.
VanPatten, B. (1996). Input Processing and Grammar Instruction.
VanPatten, B. (2004). Processing Instruction: Theory, Research, and Commentary.
VanPatten, B. & Oikkenon, S. (1996). Explanation versus Structured Input in Processing Instruction.Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 18, 495–510.
Extensive Processing Instruction (EPI) is strongly aligned with Rosenshine’s Principles of Instruction, although EPI goes considerably further by providing a language-specific, psycholinguistically informed instructional sequence which operationalises many of those principles through the MARS EARS framework.
The important distinction is that, whereas Rosenshine identifies broad principles of effective instruction, EPI translates many of them into a coherent progression from modelling and input processing to structured production, automatisation and spontaneous communication.
How EPI aligns with Rosenshine’s 10 Principles of Instruction
Rosenshine’s principle
How EPI operationalises it through MARS EARS
1. Begin a lesson with a short review
Systematic retrieval of previously taught chunks, vocabulary and structures through starters, cumulative listening and reading texts, recycled sentence builders and interleaving. Retrieval is distributed throughout the lesson, not confined to its beginning.
2. Present new material in small steps
New language is introduced through carefully selected high-frequency chunks and sentence patterns. Cognitive load is managed by controlling novelty and gradually increasing processing demands, moving from supported recognition to independent production.
3. Ask many questions and check all responses
Frequent comprehension checks, meaning-focused questioning, aural discrimination, mini-whiteboards, true/false tasks and error detection ensure active participation and provide evidence of learning across the class.
4. Provide models
Sentence builders, teacher modelling, aural input, worked examples and repeated encounters with target patterns establish accurate phonological, lexical and syntactic representations before independent production.
5. Guide student practice
Structured Production progresses through paired chunking and reading aloud activities, vocabulary building and micro-writing, paired oral retrieval, mini-roleplays, automaticity activities and communicative tasks. Scaffolding is progressively withdrawn.
6. Check for student understanding
Diagnostic checks during Awareness-raising and Receptive Processing, alongside Autonomy checkpoints, establish whether learners can recognise, understand, manipulate and independently retrieve the target language. Frequent use of mini whiteboards in both the receptive and productive activities occurs throughout the MARSEARS sequence providing tons of formative data.
7. Obtain a high success rate
Comprehensible input, carefully controlled task demands, extensive scaffolding and gradual increases in difficulty maximise successful processing and retrieval without eliminating appropriate challenge.
8. Provide scaffolds for difficult tasks
Sentence builders, narrow input, partially completed texts, visual support, substitution tables and guided production reduce unnecessary cognitive demands. Scaffolds are systematically faded as competence increases.
9. Require and monitor independent practice
Autonomy, Routinization and Spontaneity progressively require learners to retrieve, assemble and use language without sentence builders. Teachers monitor accuracy, fluency, retrieval speed and independent communicative performance.
10. Engage students in weekly and monthly review
Spaced retrieval, cumulative recycling, interleaving and recurring high-frequency constructions ensure previously taught language is revisited across lessons, units and terms in varied communicative contexts.
Where EPI goes beyond Rosenshine
Although the correspondence is substantial, EPI should not be presented merely as Rosenshine applied to languages. It offers several additional dimensions which Rosenshine’s principles do not explicitly specify.
Additional dimension
What EPI contributes
Psycholinguistic sequencing
A principled progression from phonological and meaning-focused processing to syntactic encoding, retrieval, automatisation and spontaneous production.
Listening-first instruction
Systematic development of phonological representations, speech segmentation and aural processing before learners are expected to produce unfamiliar language independently.
Input processing before output
Extensive sentence-level and connected-text receptive work designed to strengthen form–meaning mappings before learners undertake increasingly demanding production.
Lexicogrammatical instruction
Vocabulary and grammar are taught together through high-frequency constructions and chunks, with explicit grammatical awareness developed in context.
Automaticity and fluency
Dedicated Routinization activities aim to increase retrieval speed, processing efficiency and the automatic deployment of familiar language.
Spontaneous communication
The instructional sequence culminates in less predictable communicative performance, requiring learners to retrieve, assemble and adapt language with decreasing external support.
Diagnostic autonomy checkpoints
Low-stakes assessments at the end of MARSEA sub-units check independent listening, reading, writing and speaking performance, generating evidence for responsive teaching.
An important qualification
The alignment is both conceptual and pedagogical, but, of course, not evidence that Rosenshine experimentally validated EPI. Whilst Rosenshine’s principles synthesise broad findings about effective instruction, EPI goes much further by integrating those principles with solid theories and evidence concerning second-language acquisition, cognitive processing, skill acquisition and memory.
In other words Rosenshine tells teachers what effective instruction should generally involve; EPI provides language teachers with a more specific account of how to sequence instruction so that learners move from understanding language to retrieving, assembling and using it fluently and spontaneously.
In that sense, Rosenshine provides many of the instructional principles, while MARS EARS provides a language-specific instructional architecture through which those principles can be enacted.
Are we adapting language teaching to the needs of today’s learners, or inadvertently reinforcing the very habits that make language acquisition more difficult?
By Gianfranco Conti, PhD
Introduction: A changing world, an unchanged learning architecture
A few months ago, I delivered a keynote in Sydney entitled Language Teaching at a Crossroads: Engagement, Evidence, and the AI Disruption, in which I explored a number of challenges confronting language education today, from declining uptake and growing disengagement to the impact of digital technology, fragmented attention and artificial intelligence on the way young people approach learning, particularly learning which, by its very nature, requires sustained effort, repeated practice and the ability to tolerate uncertainty over relatively long periods of time.
One of the central arguments I advanced during that keynote, and which I would like to explore in greater depth here, is that we may be witnessing an increasingly problematic mismatch between the cognitive and affective enviroment in which today’s students are growing up and the conditions that we know from decades of research in cognitive psychology and Second Language Acquisition (SLA), are conducive to the development of durable linguistic knowledge and fluent and spontaneous communication.
Whilst the fundamental architecture of human cognition has not changed, the experiences, habits and expectations that learners bring into our classrooms may be actually changing in ways which make certain aspects of language acquisition more challenging, especially when the learning process requires them to engage in activities whose benefits are not immediately apparent, to revisit material they believe they have already mastered, to persevere when comprehension is incomplete and to accept that successful performance today does not necessarily guarantee successful performance tomorrow.
We are, in other words, asking students who have grown up in a world characterised by instant access to information, rapid stimulation, sophisticated digital assistance and unprecedented opportunities for immediate gratification to engage in a learning process which often operates according to an entirely different timetable, one in which progress is cumulative, forgetting is inevitable, mistakes are unavoidable and the rewards of sustained effort may not become fully apparent for weeks, months or even years.
This is what I call the Great Mismatch, although I should immediately clarify that I am not suggesting that today’s students are somehow cognitively inferior to previous generations, that their attention spans have universally deteriorated or that digital technology is inherently detrimental to learning, since such sweeping generalisations would be difficult to substantiate and would risk turning a potentially useful pedagogical discussion into yet another exercise in generational stereotyping.
Indeed, whilst research on attention, cognitive offloading, multitasking and self-regulated learning provides good reasons to be concerned about some of the habits encouraged by contemporary digital environments, we do not possess conclusive longitudinal evidence demonstrating that these environments have caused a general decline in young people’s capacity to acquire foreign languages, and it would therefore be intellectually dishonest to present what is a theoretically grounded hypothesis as an established empirical fact
Nevertheless, the absence of definitive causal evidence should not prevent us from examining the possibility that certain features of contemporary life may encourage patterns of behaviour which sit uneasily alongside the demands of language acquisition, particularly when those patterns interact with curricular and instructional practices that have long been problematic, including excessive content coverage, insufficient recycling, premature production demands and assessment procedures which often confuse immediate performance with durable learning.
And this raises a question which, in my view, ought to inform the entire discussion: are today’s students genuinely finding language learning harder because their habits and expectations have changed, or are contemporary conditions simply exposing the limitations of teaching approaches and curricula which were never particularly well aligned with the cognitive requirements of acquisition in the first place?
My suspicion is that both explanations contain elements of truth, and that the most productive response is therefore neither to blame young people for their supposed inability to concentrate nor to redesign language education around every habit that the digital world may be encouraging, but to reconsider how we can create learning environments which acknowledge contemporary realities whilst deliberately cultivating the cognitive, linguistic and affective dispositions that successful language acquisition requires.
1. The Great Mismatch: when language acquisition clashes with the expectation of immediate success
One of the most important things we know about second-language acquisition is that the development of fluent, spontaneous and accurate language use is a gradual, cumulative process which requires extensive exposure to comprehensible input, repeated opportunities to process linguistic patterns, retrieval practice and increasingly demanding opportunities to deploy previously encountered language under conditions which approximate those of real communication.
Although learners may understand a grammatical explanation within minutes, recognise a lexical item after a handful of encounters or complete a controlled exercise successfully immediately after modelling, none of these achievements necessarily demonstrates that the relevant knowledge has become sufficiently accessible, robust or automatised to support rapid retrieval during spontaneous communication, when attentional resources must be allocated simultaneously to meaning, formulation, grammatical encoding, monitoring and interactional demands.
Research on skill acquisition, including the work brought together by one of my favourite applied linguists, DeKeyser (2007), provides a useful framework for understanding why the transition from initial understanding to increasingly fluent performance requires extensive practice, whilst the distinction between short-term performance and durable learning discussed by Soderstrom and Bjork (2015) reminds us that the apparent success we observe during instruction may tell us considerably less about long-term retention and transfer than we sometimes assume.
Yet, whilst language acquisition continues to operate according to these cognitive constraints the wider environment in which many students spend a substantive proportion of their time increasingly offers experiences characterised by immediacy, convenience and rapid resolution, whereby information can be retrieved almost instantaneously, unfamiliar vocabulary translated within seconds and sophisticated written products generated with minimal independente linguistic effort.
I am not suggesting that these technological affordances inevitably make learners impatient o incapable of sustained effort, since the relationship between technology use and cognitive behaviour is considerably more complex than such an interpretation would imply; however, it seems reasonable to ask whether repeated exposure to environments in which effort can frequently be bypassed, uncertainty rapidly resolved and successful outcomes obtained almost immediately might influence what learners come to expect from educational activities whose rewards are considerably more delayed.
Consider, for example, the student who has spent twenty minutes practising a set of French structures and who, having successfully completed several activities during the lesson, discovers the following week that retrieving those same structures remains difficult, or the learner who can recognise a grammatical pattern in a reading passage but struggles to use it spontaneously when speaking, despite having apparently understood the teacher’s explanation.
From the perspective of cognitive psychology, neither experience is particularly surprising, since forgetting, retrieval difficulty and the discrepancy between recognition and independent production are familiar features of learning; from the perspective of a student who has come to associate successful task completion with immediate mastery, however, these experiences may be interpreted as evidence that the learning process is ineffective, excessively difficult or simply not worth the effort.
The danger, therefore, is not merely that students may become frustrated when learning takes longer than expected, but that they may develop inaccurate beliefs about what successful learning should feel like, particularly when effortful retrieval is interpreted as failure rather than as a potentially productive component of consolidation.
The growing discomfort of not knowing
A related concern involves what educational psychologists commonly refer to as ambiguity tolerance, namely the capacity to operate productively in situations where information is incomplete, meanings are uncertain and immediate resolution is not available, a disposition which is particularly relevant to language learning because successful comprehension and communication frequently require learners to make provisional interpretations on the basis of partial linguistic knowledge.
When listening to authentic or semi-authentic speech, learners may understand only some of the words they hear, whilst the meaning of unfamiliar expressions must be inferred from contextual information, grammatical relationships and the surrounding discourse; similarly, when reading, they may need to tolerate lexical gaps, identify referents across sentences and construct an interpretation without being able to decode every individual element.
These are not peripheral demands which can simply be removed from language learning without consequences, but integral features of developing the ability to understand and communicate beyond a narrowly rehearsed repertoire, especially as learners progress towards more independent and spontaneous language use.
However, in a world where an unfamiliar expression can be translated instantly and an incomprehensible passage explained by AI within seconds, it is worth considering whether some learners may become less inclined to persevere with the interpretative processes through which their linguistic competence could develop, not because technology has somehow damaged their cognitive capacities, but because external assistance has made it increasingly easy to avoid the discomfort associated with uncertainty.
This does not mean that dictionaries, translation tools or AI-generated explanations should be excluded from language classrooms, since they can clearly support learning when used strategically; rather, it means that we need to distinguish between assistance which enables learners to engage more effectively with challenging input and assistance which removes the very cognitive operations that an activity was intended to develop.
A student who consults a dictionary after attempting to infer the meaning of an unfamiliar word may benefit from the confirmation or correction of their hypothesis, whereas a student who immediately translates an entire passage without attempting to process its linguistic structure may complete the task successfully whilst engaging in considerably less independent language processing.
The pedagogical challenge, therefore, is not to eliminate uncertainty, nor to expose learners to incomprehensible input in the mistaken belief that struggle automatically produces learning, but to scaffold ambiguity progressively, so that students develop the confidence and strategies required to operate successfully even when their linguistic knowledge remains incomplete.
2. The illusion of engagement: when entertainment becomes a pedagogical objective
One of the developments which has concerned me increasingly over the years, particularly as I have worked with thousands of language teachers across different educational systems, is the growing tendency to equate effective teaching with the ability to generate constant visible engagement, as though a lesson in which students are animated, enthusiastic and apparently enjoying themselves must necessarily be producing more substantial learning than one in which they are quietly engaged in demanding linguistic processing.
Of course, enjoyment matters, and I would be the last person to suggest that language lessons should be dull, joyless or unnecessarily repetitive, especially given the important contribution that positive classroom experiences can make to motivation, participation and willingness to communicate; however, the assumption that visible enthusiasm provides a reliable indication of learning is problematic, because the cognitive processes responsible for durable acquisition are not always the ones which produce the most immediately impressive classroom performances.
A lesson may involve considerable movement, competition, digital interaction and laughter whilst requiring relatively little retrieval, discrimination, grammatical processing or sustained attention to meaning, just as a quieter activity involving careful listening, repeated reading, sentence reconstruction or the retrieval of previously encountered patterns may generate considerably more substantial linguistic engagement despite appearing less exciting to an external observer.
This distinction becomes particularly important when we consider the research on learning versus performance, which demonstrates that conditions producing rapid, accurate responses during practice do not necessarily produce the strongest long-term retention, especially when the support available during initial performance is removed or when learners are required to transfer their knowledge to less familiar contexts (Soderstrom & Bjork, 2015).
In other words, the fact that students are successfully completing an activity, or indeed enjoying it enormously, tells us relatively little about what they will be able to retrieve independently a week later, unless we examine the linguistic operations required by the task and the extent to which those operations are likely to contribute to durable learning.
I have observed lessons in which students appeared thoroughly engaged in competitive vocabulary games, responding rapidly and enthusiastically to familiar prompts, only to discover that their ability to retrieve the same language under less predictable conditions remained extremely limited, which should remind us that the distinction between activity completion and acquisition is not merely theoretical but has very practical consequences for how we evaluate instructional effectiveness.
This is not an argument against games, since a well-designed game can generate intensive retrieval, repeated meaning discrimination and purposeful language processing, nor is it an argument in favour of worksheets, which can be equally superficial when learners are merely copying, matching or manipulating language without meaningful cognitive engagement.
Rather, the crucial question is whether the activity requires students to perform the kinds of linguistic operations which are relevant to the intended learning outcome, and whether those operations are practised with sufficient frequency, variation and independence to support retention and transfer. In my ‘Meaningful fun’ workshops I make the argument that whilst some games can be purely motivational, the vast majority should have a strong pedagogical rationale which must justify the time and effort invested in them.
There is, however, another dimension to this issue which I believe deserves greater scrutiny, namely the possibility that our understandable desire to make lessons appealing to students who are accustomed to highly stimulating digital environments may sometimes encourage us to adopt instructional practices which reinforce the very habits that make sustained learning more challenging.
If we respond to every sign of boredom by introducing another game, changing the activity or increasing the level of stimulation, are we helping learners develop the capacity to engage with demanding material over time, or are we inadvertently teaching them that learning is worthwhile only when it provides continuous entertainment?
And if we organise lessons around the assumption that students cannot sustain attention unless the activity changes every few minutes, might we be reducing the opportunities through which they could gradually develop the attentional stamina required for more complex linguistic processing?
I should emphasise that short activities are not inherently problematic, since a sequence of carefully connected tasks which progressively deepen processing of the same linguistic material can be highly effective, particularly with novice learners whose working-memory resources are heavily taxed by unfamiliar language.The problem arises when novelty becomes an end in itself, when the purpose of changing activities is primarily to maintain stimulation rather than to develop learning, and when the success of a lesson is judged more by the intensity of students’ visible participation than by what they can subsequently understand, retrieve and use independently.
Perhaps, therefore, rather than constantly asking how we can make language learning more entertaining, we should also ask how we can help students derive increasing satisfaction from the experience of mastering something which initially appeared difficult, since engagement rooted in growing competence may be more sustainable than engagement which depends primarily on external stimulation.
3. When failure breeds disengagement: the self-efficacy problem
Whenever declining uptake, poor participation or low motivation in language learning are discussed, particularly in the context of GCSE and other high-stakes qualifications, we frequently hear explanations which attribute these difficulties to students’ lack of interest, insufficient resilience or unwillingness to make the effort required to succeed, as though disengagement were necessarily the cause of poor achievement rather than, in many cases, one of its consequences.
Yet, having worked with language teachers and observed classrooms across numerous educational contexts globally, I have become increasingly convinced that we sometimes reverse the direction of causality, because students who repeatedly fail to understand spoken language, struggle to retrieve vocabulary, experience grammatical explanations as confusing and find spontaneous communication intimidating may gradually disengage not because they were initially uninterested in learning, but because the learning experiences they have accumulated have convinced them that success is unlikely.
Consider the student who, despite apparently paying attention during lessons, repeatedly discovers that they cannot remember the language they were taught the previous week, or the learner who can complete written exercises successfully but becomes almost paralysed when asked to produce a sentence orally, especially in front of classmates whose judgement they may fear.
If such experiences are repeated often enough, and particularly if the student receives little evidence of genuine improvement, the interpretation of difficulty may gradually shift from the relatively constructive belief that more practice is needed to the far more damaging conviction that they are simply incapable of learning languages.
Bandura’s (1997) work on self-efficacy is particularly relevant here, because learners’ beliefs about their ability to succeed influence not only how much effort they are prepared to invest but also how they interpret setbacks, how long they persevere when difficulties arise and whether they approach challenging tasks as opportunities for growth or as threats to their sense of competence.
Importantly, Bandura identified successful mastery experiences as a particularly influential source of self-efficacy, which has profound implications for language teaching because it suggests that confidence should not be treated merely as a desirable emotional prerequisite for learning, but also as something which can emerge from carefully structured experiences of genuine success.
During my keynote, I proposed that sustained motivation in language learning depends substantially on the interaction between self-efficacy, perceived relevance and enjoyment, whilst being negatively affected by the costs learners associate with participation, including effort, anxiety, embarrassment and the prospect of repeated failure, a conceptualisation which is broadly compatible with expectancy-value approaches to motivation (Eccles & Wigfield, 2020).
From this perspective, it becomes easier to understand why simply making lessons more entertaining may have limited long-term effects on motivation when students continue to experience the underlying learning process as unsuccessful, since enjoyment generated by an activity may not compensate for a persistent belief that one lacks the ability to acquire the language.
The emotional cost of speaking another language
Language learning is particularly vulnerable to these dynamics because, unlike many other school subjects, it frequently requires students to expose their limitations publicly, producing unfamiliar sounds, constructing sentences with an incomplete linguistic repertoire and communicating ideas in ways which may make them appear considerably less articulate than they are in their first language.
For adolescents, whose social identities and relationships with peers can be particularly salient, the prospect of making mistakes publicly may carry substantial emotional costs, especially when the learner has already experienced repeated difficulties and has begun to associate language lessons with embarrassment or failure.
Research on foreign-language anxiety, including MacIntyre and Gardner’s (1994) work on its effects on cognitive processing, provides good reasons to take these concerns seriously, although we should avoid assuming that contemporary adolescents are necessarily more anxious or less resilient than previous generations without appropriate comparative evidence.
What is worth investigating, however, is whether contemporary experiences of digital visibility, social comparison and increasingly polished forms of self-presentation may intensify the discomfort associated with imperfect performance for some learners, particularly when they are accustomed to environments in which mistakes can be corrected, edited or concealed before an audience sees the final product.
The pedagogical response, in my view, should not be to eliminate spontaneous speaking, avoid demanding communicative tasks or reassure students that accuracy does not matter, because such responses may inadvertently reinforce the perception that imperfect performance is something to be feared. Instead, we need to create carefully sequenced opportunities through which students can move from supported rehearsal to increasingly independent communication, experiencing enough success along the way to develop the confidence required to tolerate uncertainty and take linguistic risks.
This is why I have always attached considerable importance to modelling, extensive receptive processing, structured oral retrieval and the gradual transition towards less predictable communicative interaction, since the objective is not simply to make speaking easier but to ensure that learners acquire the linguistic resources and confidence which make more demanding speaking possible.
The challenge is to develop communicative courage through successful, progressively demanding experiences, rather than either exposing students prematurely to repeated failure or protecting them indefinitely from the very difficulties they eventually need to overcome.
4. Fragmented attention and the demands of language processing
Another concern which deserves careful consideration is the relationship between contemporary patterns of attentional switching and the cognitive demands of language acquisition, particularly because many of the processes involved in understanding and producing language require learners to maintain, manipulate and integrate information over time.
Research on task switching has demonstrated that moving repeatedly between tasks incurs measurable cognitive costs (Rubinstein, Meyer & Evans, 2001), whilst studies of digital multitasking have shown that dividing attention during learning can impair comprehension and performance, including in classroom-related contexts (Sana, Weston & Cepeda, 2013).
Similarly, Ward and colleagues (2017) found that the mere presence of a smartphone could reduce available cognitive capacity under certain experimental conditions, although these findings should not be interpreted as demonstrating that smartphones have permanently damaged young people’s attentional abilities or that an entire generation has lost the capacity to concentrate.
What they do suggest is that environments which encourage frequent interruption and divided attention may interfere with learning processes which depend on sustained cognitive engagement, and this is particularly relevant to language acquisition because understanding connected speech, reading extended texts and producing coherent discourse involve the coordination of multiple operations, many of which are not yet automatic in novice learners.
When listening to French, for example, students may need to discriminate unfamiliar phonemes, identify word boundaries in a continuous speech stream, retrieve lexical meanings, process grammatical relationships and integrate successive pieces of information into a coherent interpretation, all whilst the input continues to unfold at a pace which they cannot necessarily control. If attention is interrupted during this process, the consequences may extend beyond the loss of an isolated word or phrase, because information which was required to interpret subsequent input may no longer be available, making it considerably harder for the learner to reconstruct the intended meaning.
Similar difficulties arise during reading, where comprehension requires learners to establish relationships across clauses and sentences, track referents and maintain a developing representation of the text, whilst speaking and writing impose substantial demands on retrieval, formulation, grammatical encoding and monitoring.
For learners whose linguistic knowledge is still fragile, these operations can place considerable demands on working memory, which means that unnecessary distractions, poorly designed multitasking requirements or excessive task complexity may reduce the resources available for the processing we are trying to promote.
There is, however, an important distinction between the cognitive demands inherent in processing unfamiliar language and those which arise from the way a task has been designed, because whilst the former cannot always be removed without changing the nature of the learning objective, the latter can often be reduced through better modelling, clearer instructions, more appropriate scaffolding and a more intelligent sequencing of activities.
This distinction is particularly important when teachers interpret students’ apparent inattention as evidence of poor motivation, because a learner who is struggling to coordinate too many unfamiliar linguistic operations may appear disengaged when, in reality, the task has exceeded their available processing capacity.
And here we encounter another possible paradox: if we respond to concerns about fragmented attention by continually shortening activities, introducing unrelated tasks and increasing stimulation, might we be reducing rather than strengthening learners’ opportunities to develop sustained attentional control?
I am not advocating long, monotonous activities for their own sake, nor suggesting that novice learners should be required to concentrate on demanding input for extended periods without appropriate support, since such an approach could easily produce cognitive overload rather than productive engagement.
Rather, I would argue that we need to distinguish between short activities which form part of a coherent, cumulative processing sequence and short activities which are merely juxtaposed in order to maintain novelty, because the former can progressively deepen familiarity with linguistic patterns whereas the latter may generate a great deal of classroom activity without sufficient consolidation.
The objective should therefore be to design learning experiences which are sensitive to learners’ current attentional capacities whilst gradually extending them, so that adaptation to contemporary learners does not become synonymous with the permanent lowering of our expectations concerning sustained cognitive effort.
5. Cognitive overload: when instructional failure is mistaken for student failure
One of the most significant contributions of cognitive science to education has been to demonstrate that learning is constrained by the limited capacity of working memory, particularly when students are required to process unfamiliar information which has not yet been organised into sufficiently accessible knowledge structures.
Cognitive Load Theory, associated particularly with the work of Sweller (1988) and Sweller, van Merriënboer and Paas (1998), provides a useful framework for understanding why instructional tasks can become unnecessarily demanding when learners must coordinate too many unfamiliar elements simultaneously, and why the amount and organisation of information presented during instruction can have important consequences for learning.
Consider, for example, a beginner who is expected to retrieve unfamiliar vocabulary, manipulate a recently introduced grammatical structure, remember the appropriate word order, monitor agreement and produce a complete sentence, all whilst attempting to communicate a meaningful message to a partner.Although each of these operations may be relatively manageable in isolation, their combined demands may exceed the learner’s available working-memory resources, especially when the relevant lexical and grammatical knowledge has not yet become sufficiently accessible to support rapid retrieval.
The resulting hesitation, errors or avoidance may then be interpreted as evidence that the student has not paid attention, lacks confidence or simply needs to try harder, when the more plausible explanation may be that the instructional demands were poorly calibrated to the learner’s current level of competence.
If this happens repeatedly, the consequences can extend beyond the immediate task, because excessive cognitive demands may generate unsuccessful performance, unsuccessful performance may undermine self-efficacy, and reduced self-efficacy may increase anxiety and avoidance, thereby creating a self-reinforcing cycle in which cognitive and affective difficulties progressively exacerbate one another.
This is why I believe that the sequencing of receptive and productive activities deserves far greater attention than it often receives, particularly in classrooms where students are expected to engage in relatively independent speaking or writing before they have had sufficient opportunities to process, recognise and retrieve the language required for those tasks.
I am not suggesting that production should be postponed indefinitely, nor that beginners should never attempt to formulate language before they have fully mastered it, because output can itself generate valuable learning opportunities, especially when learners receive appropriate feedback and are encouraged to notice gaps in their knowledge.However, there is an important difference between output which stretches an emerging competence and output which demands the simultaneous deployment of linguistic resources that have barely been established, just as there is a difference between meaningful challenge and difficulty generated primarily by insufficient preparation.
And this is where I believe the discussion about contemporary learners needs to become more self-critical, because some of the difficulties we attribute to their supposedly declining attention spans, resilience or willingness to work may actually be the consequences of instructional practices which have long been poorly aligned with the cognitive requirements of acquisition.
When curricula introduce too much language too quickly, when grammatical structures are taught briefly and then abandoned, when vocabulary is assessed before it has been sufficiently consolidated and when learners are expected to produce language independently before they have developed the necessary processing fluency, we should hardly be surprised if many students struggle, lose confidence and eventually disengage.
Contemporary digital habits may intensify some of these difficulties, but they cannot reasonably be held responsible for instructional weaknesses which existed long before smartphones, social media or generative AI became part of students’ everyday lives.
Therefore, before asking why today’s students appear less willing to persevere, we should ask whether we have consistently provided them with learning experiences in which perseverance is likely to lead to recognisable success.
6. Artificial intelligence: when performance becomes detached from competence
The rapid development of generative artificial intelligence has introduced another potentially significant challenge to language education, not because AI is inherently detrimental to learning, but because it makes it increasingly easy for students to produce sophisticated linguistic outcomes without necessarily engaging in the cognitive processes through which the relevant competence would ordinarily develop.
A student can now generate a grammatically accurate French essay, obtain an apparently fluent translation, formulate a sophisticated argument or produce a polished response to a reading comprehension task without independently retrieving much of the vocabulary, processing many of the grammatical relationships or constructing the linguistic representations which the task was originally designed to elicit.
The resulting product may be impressive, and indeed considerably more accurate than anything the learner could have produced unaided, but the crucial question is whether the student has acquired anything which will subsequently enable them to perform more successfully without the same level of assistance.
This distinction between externally supported performance and independently accessible competence is not new, since learners have always used dictionaries, grammar books, model answers and other resources to support their work; what is new is the extent to which AI can now perform virtually the entire task, including the linguistic decisions which would previously have required considerable effort from the learner.
Research on cognitive offloading, including Risko and Gilbert’s (2016) review, provides a useful conceptual framework for understanding how external resources can reduce the cognitive demands of tasks, although it would be simplistic to conclude that cognitive offloading is necessarily detrimental, since appropriate external support can also free resources for more demanding forms of reasoning and learning.
The pedagogical question, therefore, is not whether students should use AI, but which cognitive operations we want them to perform independantly, which forms of assistance can facilitate learning and at what point support should be withdrawn in order to establish whether genuine competence has developed.
If the purpose of a task is to develop the ability to retrieve vocabulary and formulate sentences, allowing AI to perform those operations may undermine the intended learning process, whereas if the purpose is to evaluate linguistic accuracy, compare alternative formulations or identify weaknesses in an independently produced text, AI may provide useful opportunities for feedback and reflection.
There is also a potentially important motivational dimension, because students who become accustomed to producing polished linguistic products with minimal effort may find the experience of attempting to formulate even relatively simple sentences unaided increasingly frustrating, particularly when the discrepancy between assisted performance and independent competence becomes difficult to ignore.
A learner who can generate a sophisticated paragraph in seconds but struggles to produce a short accurate response without assistance may begin to perceive independent language production as unnecessarily laborious, especially if they do not understand why the effort involved in retrieval, formulation and self-monitoring is important for acquisition.
Under such circumstances, greater reliance on AI could reduce opportunities for independent practice, which might in turn limit the development of the very competence whose absence makes external assistance increasingly attractive, although I would stress that this remains a plausible developmental risk rather than an inevitable consequence demonstrated by long-term empirical research.
The solution, in my view, is not to prohibit AI indiscriminately, but to design learning activities in which it supports rather than replaces the cognitive processes we want students to develop, perhaps by requiring an independent attempt before AI-assisted comparison, followed by reflection, correction and a subsequent opportunity to retrieve or reconstruct the relevant language without assistance.
Used in this way, AI can become a valuable tool for enhancing feedback, providing additional input and supporting metalinguistic reflection, whilst preserving the opportunities for effortful retrieval and independent formulation which remain essential to developing fluent language use.
The guiding principle should therefore be that technology ought to reduce unnecessary obstacles to learning without removing the cognitive work through which learning actually occurs, a distinction which is likely to become increasingly important as AI systems become more sophisticated and their outputs increasingly indistinguishable from those of competent human language users.
7. Repetition, automaticity and the problem of superficial coverage
If there is one aspect of language acquisition which appears particularly difficult to reconcile with contemporary expectations of rapid progress, it is the amount of repeated processing and practice required for linguistic knowledge to become sufficiently accessible to support fluent, spontaneous communication.
Research on skill acquisition and practice, including DeKeyser (2007), provides a theoretical basis for understanding why repeated opportunities to process and use language can contribute to increasing fluency, whilst research on distributed practice (Cepeda et al., 2006) and retrieval practice (Karpicke & Roediger, 2008) demonstrates the importance of how learning opportunities are organised for long-term retention.
However, it is essential to distinguish between repetition as mere recurrence and repetition as an opportunity for meaningful cognitive processing, because repeatedly exposing learners to the same material, or asking them to complete essentially identical exercises, does not necessarily guarantee the development of flexible, transferable linguistic knowledge.
What matters is not simply how often students encounter a particular word or structure, but what they are required to do with it, how much attention they allocate to its form and meaning, whether they must retrieve it rather than merely recognise it, and whether subsequent encounters require them to process it under increasingly varied and demanding conditions.
A structure initially encountered in a sentence builder, for example, might subsequently be processed through listening activities requiring fine-grained meaning discrimination, reading tasks involving grammatical decoding, oral retrieval activities, sentence transformations and communicative tasks in which learners must select and manipulate the structure to express meanings that are not entirely predictable.
Although the linguistic content remains relatively stable across these activities, the processing demands change progressively, thereby allowing learners to consolidate familiar patterns whilst developing greater flexibility and independence in their use.
This is why I have always argued that extensive processing should not be confused with monotonous drilling, since the objective is not to repeat the same activity endlessly but to create a sufficiently rich sequence of encounters and retrieval opportunities through which linguistic knowledge becomes increasingly accessible, robust and usable.
There is, however, another problem which I believe has contributed substantially to the difficulties experienced by many language learners, namely the persistent tendency of curricula to prioritise the quantity of content covered over the depth to which that content is processed and consolidated.
In many educational contexts, students are exposed to extensive vocabulary lists, numerous grammatical structures and a succession of thematic units, often with insufficient time allocated to revisiting previously taught language or developing the retrieval fluency required for independent communication.
We then assess students on material which they may have understood during instruction but which has not been consolidated sufficiently to remain accessible over time, and interpret their subsequent difficulties as evidence of poor memory, inadequate revision or insufficient effort.
Yet if learners are continually required to process substantial quantities of new material before earlier knowledge has become sufficiently secure, the problem may lie less with their memory capacities than with a curriculum which systematically underestimates the amount of practice required for acquisition.
Indeed, one of the most important lessons we can draw from research on learning is that the successful completion of a unit does not necessarily indicate that its linguistic content has been acquired, particularly when subsequent teaching provides few opportunities for cumulative retrieval and transfer.
This is why I believe that slimmer, more carefully sequenced curricula, organised around high-frequency and communicatively useful lexical and grammatical patterns, may provide a stronger foundation for long-term progression than curricula which pursue breadth at the expense of depth.
Such an approach should not be mistaken for lowering expectations, because the ultimate objective remains the development of an increasingly extensive and flexible linguistic repertoire; rather, it recognises that breadth becomes educationally meaningful only when learners have had sufficient opportunities to consolidate the knowledge on which subsequent learning depends.
The real question, therefore, is not how much language we can teach within a given period, but how much of that language students can retain, retrieve and use when the scaffolding has been removed.
8. What should language teachers do differently?
If the arguments developed so far have any validity, the implications for language teaching are considerable, although I would resist the temptation to translate them into yet another fashionable list of classroom techniques which promises to solve complex learning problems through a handful of easily implemented strategies.
What we need, in my view, is a more fundamental reconsideration of how curricula, instructional sequences, assessment procedures and classroom expectations can be organised around the cognitive and affective conditions required for acquisition, particularly when learners may be bringing into our classrooms habits and expectations which do not always align comfortably with those conditions.
Prioritising depth, cumulative recycling and processing quality
The first priority should be to reduce the discrepancy between the quantity of linguistic material introduced and the opportunities available for consolidating it, which means identifying a manageable repertoire of high-value language and ensuring that learners encounter, process and retrieve it repeatedly across different contexts and modalities.
This does not mean that all repetition should be mechanical or that linguistic content should remain unchanged indefinitely, but that progression should be cumulative, with new material systematically connected to previously encountered patterns so that learners are continually strengthening and extending their existing knowledge rather than accumulating increasingly fragile fragments.
Sequencing comprehension and production more intelligently
A second priority involves ensuring that learners receive sufficient modelling, comprehensible input and opportunities for receptive processing before being expected to produce unfamiliar language with substantial independence, whilst recognising that the relationship between input and output is dynamic and that appropriately scaffolded production can itself contribute to learning.
The objective should be to manage cognitive demands intelligently, so that learners are challenged to retrieve and manipulate language which is becoming familiar rather than being repeatedly confronted with tasks which require the simultaneous coordination of too many poorly established linguistic elements.
Making genuine progress visible
A third priority concerns the development of self-efficacy, particularly through opportunities for students to recognise that their competence is improving, not simply because they can complete an activity successfully immediately after modelling, but because they can understand, retrieve or use language which previously required considerably more support.
Cumulative retrieval tasks, repeated listening activities, comparisons between earlier and later speaking performances and carefully designed delayed assessments can all contribute to making progress visible, provided that we remain attentive to the distinction between immediate performance and durable learning.
Developing attentional stamina and ambiguity tolerance
A fourth priority should be to create learning environments which protect attention whilst progressively developing learners’ capacity to engage with demanding linguistic material, reducing unnecessary distractions and avoiding the assumption that every activity must be brief, novel or entertaining in order to be worthwhile.
At the same time, students should gradually encounter tasks which require them to tolerate incomplete comprehension, infer meanings, manage uncertainty and communicate with an imperfect repertoire, because the ability to operate successfully without understanding or controlling every linguistic element is itself an important component of communicative competence.
Using assessment to advance learning rather than merely measure performance
A fifth priority involves reconsidering the purpose and design of formative assessment, particularly in contexts where rapid correct responses, mini-whiteboard activities and frequent quizzes are sometimes treated as sufficient evidence that learning has occurred.
Whilst such activities can provide useful diagnostic information, especially when they reveal misconceptions or allow teachers to adjust instruction, their value depends on the quality of the evidence they generate and on whether the subsequent instructional response is likely to improve learning.
A student who produces a correct answer immediately after extensive modelling may have demonstrated understanding or short-term accessibility, but not necessarily durable acquisition, which is why delayed retrieval, varied contexts and appropriately calibrated transfer tasks are needed if we want to establish whether knowledge has become more robust and independently accessible.
Furthermore, assessment activities should not be evaluated solely according to how quickly they reveal what students know, but also according to whether they encourage the kinds of retrieval, discrimination, reflection and feedback processing which can contribute to subsequent learning.
Teaching students how learning actually works
Finally, I believe we should devote more attention to helping students understand why language learning sometimes feels difficult, particularly why forgetting is normal, why repeated retrieval matters, why fluent performance requires extensive practice and why the temporary inability to remember something does not necessarily mean that previous learning has been wasted.
Such explanations should not be used to justify poorly designed instruction or to romanticise struggle, since difficulty is educationally productive only when learners have sufficient knowledge and support to engage with it successfully; nevertheless, helping students develop more accurate expectations about the learning process may reduce the likelihood that normal retrieval difficulties are interpreted as evidence of permanent inability.
9. Where Extensive Processing Instruction fits into this picture
Many of the principles discussed in this article are central to Extensive Processing Instruction (EPI), the instructional framework which I have developed over the years through my engagement with SLA research, cognitive psychology and classroom practice, and which is described in detail in Breaking the Sound Barrier.
The MARSEARS sequence, with its progression through Modelling and Awareness-Raising, Structured Receptive Processing, Structured Production, Expansion, Autonomy, Routinisation and Spontaneity, was designed to address several of the challenges explored here by ensuring that learners have repeated opportunities to process linguistic patterns before being expected to retrieve and manipulate them under increasingly demanding conditions.
Its emphasis on comprehensible modelling, extensive receptive processing, carefully scaffolded production, cumulative recycling and the gradual development of automaticity is particularly relevant to learners who may struggle with excessive cognitive demands, fragile retrieval, low self-efficacy or the expectation that successful performance should follow almost immediately from initial explanation.
When students encounter familiar patterns repeatedly across different tasks, experience success in activities which are appropriately challenging and gradually discover that language which previously required considerable effort can now be retrieved more rapidly and accurately, they are not merely consolidating linguistic knowledge but also developing the sense of competence which may encourage them to persevere when subsequent learning becomes more demanding.
I should emphasise, however, that EPI is not the only instructional approach capable of addressing these challenges, nor would it be appropriate to suggest that the research discussed in this article establishes the superiority of the complete MARSEARS sequence over every alternative methodology, since such a claim would require direct comparative evidence which goes beyond the theoretical and empirical foundations of its individual components.
Rather, EPI represents one coherent attempt to translate principles from cognitive science, skill acquisition research, input processing, retrieval practice and educational psychology into a practical instructional framework, whilst recognising that other approaches may incorporate many of the same principles and that the effectiveness of any methodology ultimately depends on the quality of its implementation and the learning outcomes it produces.
What matters, therefore, is not whether teachers adopt a particular label or sequence, but whether their instructional design provides sufficient opportunities for learners to process language meaningfully, consolidate it through repeated encounters, retrieve it with increasing independence and eventually deploy it flexibly in communicative contexts.
And this brings me back to what I consider one of the most important implications of the Great Mismatch: if we want students to become more succesful language learners, we need to teach them not only the language itself but also how to engage productively with the cognitive and affective demands of acquiring it, including the need to persevere through temporary retrieval difficulties, tolerate uncertainty, recognise the value of repetition and accept that fluent performance emerges gradually rather than immediately.
In this sense, effective language teaching may sometimes need to operate against the grain of the wider environment, not by rejecting technology, enjoyment or contemporary forms of engagement, but by deliberately cultivating dispositions which those environments may not always encourage.
Conclusion: the world has changed, but the architecture of learning has not
The world in which our students are growing up has changed profoundly, particularly in relation to how information is accessed, how attention is allocated, how quickly assistance can be obtained and how easily sophisticated products can be generated without the independent cognitive effort which would previously have been required.
Yet, despite these developments, the fundamental constraints of human cognition remain substantially unchanged, since working memory is still limited, attention remains essential to processing, forgetting continues to be an inevitable feature of learning and the development of fluent, spontaneous language use still requires extensive opportunities for meaningful processing, retrieval, consolidation and increasingly independent performance.
What concerns me is not simply that contemporary digital environments may encourage habits which conflict with some of these requirements, but that the interaction between those habits and longstanding weaknesses in language education may create particularly unfavourable conditions for learners whose confidence, attentional control and linguistic knowledge are already fragile.
A student who expects rapid success may become frustrated by the normal difficulties of retrieval, whilst insufficient practice may contribute to repeated failure, repeated failure may undermine self-efficacy, and diminished self-efficacy may encourage avoidance of the very activities which could help develop greater competence.
When AI provides an immediately accessible means of bypassing those difficulties, the temptation to substitute externally generated performance for independent learning may become even stronger, particularly if students have not developed an adequate understanding of why the cognitive effort involved in processing, retrieving and producing language is important.
This is not to suggest that such a trajectory is inevitable, that all contemporary learners exhibit these characteristics or that digital technologies are necessarily responsible for declining engagement in language education, since the empirical evidence does not justify such sweeping conclusions and the relationships involved are undoubtedly complex.
Nor should we overlook the possibility that some of the difficulties we attribute to changing student characteristics are actually being intensified by curricular and instructional practices which have long prioritised content coverage over consolidation, premature production over carefully scaffolded progression and immediate performance over durable learning.
Indeed, perhaps the Great Mismatch is not simply between the habits of today’s learners and the cognitive demands of language acquisition, but also between what decades of research have taught us about how linguistic competence develops and what our curricula, assessment systems and classroom practices continue to require students to do.
If that is the case, the solution cannot simply consist of making lessons faster, more entertaining, less demanding or increasingly dependent on technological assistance, because such adaptations may improve immediate participation without necessarily addressing the underlying cognitive and affective conditions required for acquisition.
Equally, it would be misguided to respond by romanticising struggle, demanding greater resilience without providing adequate support or assuming that students who experience repeated failure simply need to work harder, since poorly calibrated difficulty can undermine learning just as effectively as insufficient challenge.
What we need instead is an approach to language education which combines ambitious expectations with intelligent scaffolding, extensive processing with meaningful variation, cognitive challenge with genuine opportunities for success and technological innovation with a clear understanding of which mental operations learners must continue to perform for themselves.
Perhaps, therefore, one of the most important responsibilities of language teachers in the coming years will be to help students rediscover the satisfaction which comes from gradually mastering something difficult, particularly in a world where the distinction between producing an impressive outcome and possessing the competence required to produce it independently is becoming increasingly blurred.
And perhaps we should be asking ourselves whether, in our understandable desire to adapt teaching to the habits and expectations of contemporary learners, we have sometimes been too willing to accomodate those habits rather than helping students develop the dispositions which successful learning requires.
For whilst the technology has changed, the cultural environment has changed and learners’ expectations may well be changing too, the fundamental architecture of human learning has not, which means that our task is not to redesign language acquisition around the expectation of immediate gratification, but to create instructional experiences through which sustained attention, repeated processing, tolerance of uncertainty and delayed rewards become increasingly manageable, meaningful and ultimately satisfying.
The real challenge, therefore, is not simply to make language learning easier for today’s students, but to make them better equipped to engage successfully with the difficulties that meaningful language learning inevitably entails.
References
Bandura, A. (1997). Self-efficacy: The exercise of control. W. H. Freeman.
Cepeda, N. J., Pashler, H., Vul, E., Wixted, J. T., & Rohrer, D. (2006). Distributed practice in verbal recall tasks: A review and quantitative synthesis. Psychological Bulletin, 132(3), 354–380.
DeKeyser, R. M. (Ed.). (2007). Practice in a second language: Perspectives from applied linguistics and cognitive psychology. Cambridge University Press.
Eccles, J. S., & Wigfield, A. (2020). From expectancy-value theory to situated expectancy-value theory: A developmental, social cognitive, and sociocultural perspective on motivation. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 61, 101859.
Karpicke, J. D., & Roediger, H. L. (2008). The critical importance of retrieval for learning. Science, 319(5865), 966–968.
MacIntyre, P. D., & Gardner, R. C. (1994). The subtle effects of language anxiety on cognitive processing in the second language. Language Learning, 44(2), 283–305.
Risko, E. F., & Gilbert, S. J. (2016). Cognitive offloading. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 20(9), 676–688.
Rubinstein, J. S., Meyer, D. E., & Evans, J. E. (2001). Executive control of cognitive processes in task switching. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 27(4), 763–797.
Sana, F., Weston, T., & Cepeda, N. J. (2013). Laptop multitasking hinders classroom learning for both users and nearby peers. Computers & Education, 62, 24–31.
Soderstrom, N. C., & Bjork, R. A. (2015). Learning versus performance: An integrative review. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 10(2), 176–199.
Sweller, J. (1988). Cognitive load during problem solving: Effects on learning. Cognitive Science, 12(2), 257–285.
Sweller, J., van Merriënboer, J. J. G., & Paas, F. G. W. C. (1998). Cognitive architecture and instructional design. Educational Psychology Review, 10, 251–296.
Ward, A. F., Duke, K., Gneezy, A., & Bos, M. W. (2017). Brain drain: The mere presence of one’s own smartphone reduces available cognitive capacity. Journal of the Association for Consumer Research, 2(2), 140–154.
From what I see daily on social media and read in the specialized literature, much has been said about how artificial intelligence can help teachers teach more efficiently and students learn more efficiently. Yet very little is being said about its potential negative effects on teachers themselves: on their pedagogical competence, professional judgement, creativity and autonomy.
What I see as the greatest potential threat posed by AI to teacher expertise is professional deskilling: the gradual weakening of the knowledge, judgement and decision-making capacities that teachers develop through deep and sustained engagement with planning, teaching, assessment and reflection. AI may make teachers more productive without necessarily making them more competent. When teachers routinely delegate important pedagogical decisions to AI, they risk losing opportunities to develop and refine the expertise underpinning effective instruction.
Ten potential negative effects
1. Erosion of pedagogical content knowledge (PCK)
Teachers develop expertise by continually deciding how to transform subject knowledge into explanations, examples, tasks and representations that learners can understand.When AI routinely makes these decisions, teachers engage less deeply in this process. In MFL, this includes, for instance, choosing which grammatical structures to prioritise, anticipating linguistic difficulties, selecting appropriate examples, etc.
Research principle potentially undermined: Shulman’s (1986, 1987) concept of pedagogical content knowledge, emphasising the integration of subject knowledge and knowledge of how to teach it.
2. ‘Atrophy’ of instructional design skills
Designing effective lessons requires teachers to identify learning objectives, sequence content, anticipate misconceptions, manage cognitive demands and plan opportunities for practice and assessment with their students and learning setting in mind. Outsourcing lesson planning to AI obviously reduces opportunities to exercise these skills, particularly among novice teachers who have yet to develop robust instructional knowledge. This is very concerning, as the crisis we are currently experiencing in recruiting language learners at GCSE and A-level demands teachers with exceptional instructional design skills!
Research principle potentially undermined: Constructive alignment (Biggs, 1996), backward design (Wiggins & McTighe, 2005) and cognitive load theory (Sweller et al., 1998).
3. Weakening of diagnostic expertise
An important chunk of a teacher’s professional growth refers to the development ofone’s ability to interpret student errors, distinguish between different causes of misunderstanding and identify appropriate interventions.If AI increasingly diagnoses learning difficulties and recommends corrective actions, teachers will eventually become less practised at independently interpreting evidence of learning! For example, an MFL teacher might accept an AI-generated explanation of listening difficulties without investigating whether the problem concerns phonological decoding, lexical recognition, grammatical parsing or working-memory demands. Another MFL teacher delegating corrective feedback on a written piece to a bot, will miss out on an incredibly useful window into their students’ interlanguage development.
Research principle potentially undermined: Teacher noticing and professional vision (van Es & Sherin, 2002), and formative assessment as eliciting, interpreting and acting upon evidence (Black & Wiliam, 1998).
4. Reduced capacity for critical pedagogical judgement
AI-generated recommendations appear very convincing, particularly when accompanied by plausible explanations or research references. Teachers may consequently become less inclined to question instructional choices, compare alternatives or scrutinise the assumptions underlying a suggested approach. The risk is a shift from independently evaluating pedagogical options to selecting among solutions generated by an algorithm.
Research principle potentially undermined: Reflective professional judgement (Schön, 1983), educational judgement (Biesta, 2015) and automation bias (Parasuraman & Riley, 1997).
5. Reduced reflective practice
Professional expertise develops to a great extent through reflection on instructional decisions: why an activity succeeded, why students struggled and what should be changed. If AI routinely generates lesson evaluations, identifies weaknesses and recommends improvements, teachers may engage less actively in the reflective processes through which professional understanding develops.
Research principle potentially undermined: Schön’s (1983) reflection-in-action and reflection-on-action, and Kolb’s (1984) experiential learning cycle.
6. Weakening of curriculum design expertise
Curriculum planning requires complex decisions about progression, sequencing, knowledge selection, cumulative practice and assessment. AI-generated units may be superficially coherent while failing to reflect learners’ prior knowledge or the developmental demands of the subject. When teachers increasingly adopt rather than construct curriculum sequences, they may lose opportunities to understand how knowledge accumulates over time.
Research principle potentially undermined: Curriculum coherence, constructive alignment (Biggs, 1996), and spacing and distributed practice (Cepeda et al., 2006).
7. Reduced pedagogical creativity
Professional creativity involves generating, testing and refining instructional approaches in response to particular learners and contexts. AI can support creativity by suggesting alternatives, but habitual reliance on ready-made materials may reduce teachers’ opportunities for inventive problem-solving. A related danger is pedagogical homogenisation, as teachers draw on similar AI-generated lesson structures and activities.
Research principle potentially undermined: Teacher agency (Priestley, Biesta & Robinson, 2015) and adaptive expertise (Hatano & Inagaki, 1986).
8. Declining professional autonomy
As AI platforms increasingly recommend instructional strategies, assessment approaches and learning interventions, decisions traditionally made by teachers may shift towards technological systems. This becomes particularly problematic when schools institutionalise AI-generated planning or algorithmic recommendations, reducing teachers’ discretion to adapt instruction to their learners.
Research principle potentially undermined: Teacher agency and professional autonomy (Priestley, Biesta & Robinson, 2015), and educational judgement (Biesta, 2015).
9. Reduced development of novice teachers
Novice teachers acquire expertise partly by undertaking demanding professional tasks, receiving feedback, reflecting on outcomes and progressively refining their decisions. If AI routinely performs lesson planning, resource development, assessment design and diagnostic reasoning for them, beginning teachers may miss opportunities to build foundational professional skills. They may also lack the expertise required to recognise weaknesses in AI recommendations.
Research principle potentially undermined: Development of teacher expertise (Berliner, 2004), pedagogical reasoning (Shulman, 1987) and deliberate practice (Ericsson, Krampe & Tesch-Römer, 1993).
10. The illusion of professional competence
This is what I keep seeing more and more when I visit schools. AI can make relatively inexperienced or less competent teachers appear highly competent by enabling them to produce sophisticated lesson plans, assessments, presentations and instructional materials. Yet the quality of these products does not necessarily reflect underlying understanding. A teacher may become increasingly efficient at generating materials while remaining unable to explain why particular activities are appropriate, diagnose their limitations or adapt them effectively.
Research principle potentially undermined: The distinction between performance and learning (Soderstrom & Bjork, 2015), applied cautiously to professional learning, and pedagogical reasoning (Shulman, 1987).
Summary: How AI may erode teacher expertise
Dimension of expertise
Potential negative impact
Pedagogical content knowledge
Less independent transformation of subject knowledge into teachable content
Instructional design
Reduced practice in sequencing, scaffolding and planning
Diagnostic competence
Greater reliance on automated interpretations of learner difficulties
Critical judgement
Increased acceptance of algorithmic recommendations
Reflective practice
Less independent analysis of instructional successes and failures
Curriculum expertise
Reduced engagement with progression and cumulative learning
Creativity
Dependence on ready-made solutions and homogenisation of teaching
Professional autonomy
Transfer of pedagogical decisions towards AI systems
Novice teacher development
Fewer opportunities to acquire foundational professional skills
Professional self-evaluation
Confusion between AI-generated outputs and genuine teaching expertise
What does the evidence actually establish?
There is a crucial distinction between well-established research on how professional expertise develops and direct evidence that generative AI causes teacher deskilling. Research by Shulman, Schön, Berliner and others provides strong theoretical reasons to be concerned about outsourcing professional thinking. Research on automation bias demonstrates that people can become excessively reliant on automated recommendations. However, longitudinal evidence showing that regular generative AI use causes measurable deterioration in teachers’ pedagogical content knowledge, diagnostic competence or professional judgement remains limited. These are credible risks, not established universal outcomes!
The distinction also matters between AI that replaces professional reasoning and AI that stimulates it. A teacher who critically evaluates, challenges and improves AI-generated lesson plans may strengthen rather than weaken their expertise.
The central paradox
AI can dramatically increase the speed at which teachers produce lessons, worksheets, assessments and feedback. But the intellectual work involved in creating those materials is not merely an administrative burden to be eliminated. It is often part of the process through which teachers develop pedagogical expertise.
The danger is that schools may celebrate gains in teacher productivity while overlooking a gradual reduction in opportunities for teachers to practise the complex professional reasoning that makes them effective.
AI may help teachers do more, faster, while giving them fewer opportunities to become better at what they do.
That is arguably the most important long-term concern about AI and teacher professional development.
Selected research references
Berliner, D. C. (2004). Describing the behavior and documenting the accomplishments of expert teachers. Bulletin of Science, Technology & Society, 24(3), 200–212.
Biesta, G. (2015). What is education for? On good education, teacher judgement, and educational professionalism. European Journal of Education, 50(1), 75–87.
Black, P., & Wiliam, D. (1998). Assessment and classroom learning. Assessment in Education, 5(1), 7–74.
Cepeda, N. J., et al. (2006). Distributed practice in verbal recall tasks: A review and quantitative synthesis. Psychological Bulletin, 132(3), 354–380.
Ericsson, K. A., Krampe, R. T., & Tesch-Römer, C. (1993). The role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance. Psychological Review, 100(3), 363–406.
Hatano, G., & Inagaki, K. (1986). Two courses of expertise. In Child Development and Education in Japan.
Parasuraman, R., & Riley, V. (1997). Humans and automation: Use, misuse, disuse, abuse. Human Factors, 39(2), 230–253.
Priestley, M., Biesta, G., & Robinson, S. (2015). Teacher Agency: An Ecological Approach. Bloomsbury.
Schön, D. A. (1983). The Reflective Practitioner. Basic Books.
Shulman, L. S. (1986). Those who understand: Knowledge growth in teaching. Educational Researcher, 15(2), 4–14.
Shulman, L. S. (1987). Knowledge and teaching: Foundations of the new reform. Harvard Educational Review, 57(1), 1–22.
Soderstrom, N. C., & Bjork, R. A. (2015). Learning versus performance: An integrative review. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 10(2), 176–199.
van Es, E. A., & Sherin, M. G. (2002). Learning to notice: Scaffolding new teachers’ interpretations of classroom interactions. Journal of Technology and Teacher Education, 10(4), 571–596.
You must be logged in to post a comment.